Cocaine exhibit theft and premature destruction
The allegation. On 22 June 2021 police seized 541 kilograms of cocaine at Isipingo in a joint Hawks and Crime Intelligence operation. Instead of going to a forensic science laboratory — where, Major General Senona testified, such drugs would normally be stored — the haul was placed in a strongroom at the Port Shepstone Serious Organised Crime office. Months later it was gone. Senona told the commission the cocaine stored there was stolen. The chairperson put it that the question of who stole it remains, and that someone was pushing for the urgent destruction of what was believed to be cocaine.
How it allegedly worked. Colonel Gavin Jacob testified that he received information from Captain Duma of Crime Intelligence on the morning of 22 June 2021 about cocaine in a container, and that inspected bags held suspected one-kilogram bricks. The consignment was never sealed as the rules require: Jacob said the non-availability of exhibit bags was why the exhibits were not sealed as per National Instruction 8 of 2017. Major General Flynn testified that the storage decision followed consultation with Senona, who then took possession of the strongroom keys; Brigadier Nyuswa said Senona took both the original and the spare key. Warrant Officer Mpangase said Jacob instructed that the exhibits be booked out and taken to Port Shepstone, while counsel put a version that Jacob directed them to Isipingo SAPS. Warrant Officer Setshedi's evidence referred to a warning on 27 October 2021 that people were planning to break into the office to steal the drugs. Adv Khumalo SC put that the drugs were stolen some ten days later, on 8 November.
Who is named. Senona, appointed Provincial Head of the DPCI in KwaZulu-Natal around August 2020, is the official most often the subject of the evidence. Mr Vusimuzi "Cat" Matlala testified that he met Senona at a funeral, exchanged numbers with him at a later stage, and borrowed R20,000 from him. A chat dated 15 January 2025, read into evidence, has Senona saying that if things are favourable "let us finalise the contract for those guys who assisted us". Senona rejected the suggestion that he transferred Warrant Officer Karl Sander for nefarious reasons, saying it was "just not true". On 23 November 2021 he asked the national head to authorise polygraph tests for Port Shepstone members and the seizing officers; counsel put that he excluded himself and Brigadier Nyuswa.
Conduct alleged to be unlawful. the theft of a state drug exhibit from a police strongroom; breaches of National Instruction 8 of 2017, which counsel described as requiring seized exhibits to be entered in the SAP13 property register; and key-handling without records, which Adv Sello SC said carried the risk of pilfering each time the keys changed hands. Against this, Jacob attributed the unsealed exhibits to a shortage of bags, and Mpangase said he does not know who broke into the Port Shepstone storage.
The commission has not yet made findings. This overview summarises what was alleged in evidence; each number opens the claim it rests on.