WhatTheySaid.co.zaThe Madlanga Commission record, in plain language
SC0007

Carrim / Mogotsi / Matlala loan chain + ANC event payments

The allegation. According to evidence before the commission, a businessman, Mr Carrim, put millions of rands into the business of police contractor Mr Vusimuzi "Cat" Matlala, and money flowed out again — including to African National Congress events. Mr Brown Mogotsi testified that he was aware Carrim was an investor in the contract or tender awarded to Matlala by the South African Police Service. Carrim testified that his investment was R10 million "and nothing more"; Adv Chaskalson SC put to him that he advanced 10 million and would receive a return of an additional 10 million. Lieutenant General Khumalo testified that Matlala's payments were sometimes for expenses related to ANC events and for the benefit of delegates, and that Carrim appeared to be paid by Matlala. Mogotsi said Matlala assisted with funding transport, entertainment and accommodation for ANC members attending an ANC celebration in Cape Town.

How it allegedly worked. The money moved through companies rather than directly between people. A document records outgoing payments from Tameez Investments to Carrim and Mogotsi, and confirms Carrim as that company's bankcard holder. Carrim testified that Tameez "lent money to Mr Matlala via Ziggy". Adv Baloyi SC referred to a R10 million Ziggy payment and put to Carrim that he had advanced a loan to Matlala. Repayment then stalled. Carrim testified that Matlala owed him money and that he pressed him continuously for his monies. A message read into evidence shows Matlala following up with Carrim about "payment" on 30 January 2025. Carrim said Mogotsi already knew the SAPS contract was ending, and that Matlala picked this up from Mogotsi.

Who is named. The central figures are Carrim, Matlala and Mogotsi. Matlala appeared before the commission, where Adv Sello SC asked him about "the loan advanced by Mr Karim to you" and put to him that a Regulation 10(6) notice required him to address his involvement in the loan or funding agreement with Carrim. Mogotsi's role is contested. In a recusal application he brought against the evidence leader, Adv Chaskalson SC categorically denied inviting Mogotsi to give false evidence against Carrim, or suggesting he would be shielded from adverse findings.

Conduct alleged to be unlawful. Mr O'Sullivan told the commission he regarded the dealings as "part of the generally corrupt relationship". Carrim testified that other invoices were paid which were not disclosed to him, and that he remained owed money. Much remains untested. The chairperson said information Carrim had undertaken to furnish remained outstanding, and Adv Hassim SC said companies linked to him do business in hundreds of millions of rands. The chairperson said Carrim had refused an independent medical assessment, that the commission could not force him, and that this was the end of the road. Carrim's counsel, Mr Premhid, said a mechanism had been proactively offered and that they would cooperate.

The commission has not yet made findings. This overview summarises what was alleged in evidence; each number opens the claim it rests on.

23 events1 contradictionsR10,000,000
People in this scheme
Suliman Carim33Brown Mogotsi31Mr Vusimuzi 'Cat' Matlala11Advocate Ramsamy2Advocate Johnson2Adv Chaskalson SC2Lieutenant General Godfrey Lebeya2Adv Lee Segeels-Ncube1
Timeline of events
●
September 2023
The Brown Mogotsi Foundation, with Mogotsi deposing affidavits, interdicted a tender process by the North West Health Department. Funding for the legal action came from Carrim and Kareem.
action taken: when your foundation interdicted the North West Health Department around a tender?
Day 36 · Adv Chaskalson SC ·
role in case: did you depose to all of the affidavits in this case as the named member of the foundation?
Day 36 · Adv Chaskalson SC ·
See all 5 claims →
R
12 December 2023
Suleiman Carrim transferred R35 million to Vusimuzi Matlala on 12 December 2023. Carrim later said he believed this was in advance of a preservation order.
belief: there being no basis for him to believe that the statement would not be kept confidential
Day 72 · Chairperson ·
belief: I saw it now in my books
Day 73 · Mr Carrim ·
See all 6 claims →
R
February 2024
Suleiman Carrim made initial payments totalling millions of rand to Morgan Maumela, facilitated by Vusimuzi Matlala, as part of the Medicare 24 contract arrangement in the lead-up to the SAPS award.
received payment: in Feb you received your first payment
Day 73 · Mr Carrim ·
action taken: Around Feb, March of 2024, Counsel
Day 73 · Mr Carrim ·
See all 12 claims →
order between these two not established
●
21 March 2024
Matlala arranged delivery of impalas from a Rudy Farm manager on 21 March 2024, with payment and address details exchanged via WhatsApp — illustrating the informal gift and livestock economy around the network.
message content: Rudy Farm Manager then says: "Thank you, sir, I got it, thank you very much, thanks sir, we will do that."
Day 52 · Adv Chaskalson SC ·
message content: Rudy Farm Manager responds: "Thanks sir, hi there sir, okay, everything has been arranged, he will catch the Impalas on Sunday and transport it Monday to that location. Is it good?"
Day 52 · Adv Chaskalson SC ·
See all 6 claims →
●
30 September 2024
Brown Mogotsi sent his first WhatsApp message to Lt-Gen Mkhwanazi on 30 September 2024, introducing himself and claiming to have information about a plot to discredit Mkhwanazi.
text: the first wording he says: “My General Brown Mogotsi from North West.”
Day 2 · Lt Gen Mkhwanazi ·
sender: Brown Mogotsi from North West
Day 3 · Lt Gen Mkhwanazi ·
See all 26 claims →
●
December 2024
Mogotsi participated in a covert section 252(A) recording operation to capture conversations about a plot to remove General Khan from his position, involving senior officers. The operation was authorised.
action sequence: I heard him when he was here, if you remember Commissioners, he said after he has accepted to preside over General Khan's disciplinary hearing, I started talking to him. It is true. That was the perio
Day 35 · Brown Mogotsi ·
obtained in presence of: it was done in my presence, by my handler, because it was a verbal authority.
Day 35 · Brown Mogotsi ·
See all 8 claims →
order between these two not established
●
6 December 2024
Vusimuzi Matlala alleged that he and his wife were assaulted on 6 December 2024. Mogotsi was aware of the allegations.
awareness of: I was aware that Mr Kareem was an investor in the contract or tender awarded to Matlala by the South African Police Service
Day 35 · Brown Mogotsi ·
awareness of: Yes, I did. And even if those people could have been arrested, there was no need for me to tell the Minister.
Day 37 · Brown Mogotsi ·
See all 3 claims →
●
23 December 2024
Mogotsi sent a WhatsApp message to Minister Mchunu on 23 December 2024 stating "We got a breakthrough", referring to progress in the effort to arrest Lt-Gen Mkhwanazi.
sent message content: you sent the Minister a message saying: 'We got a breakthrough.'
Day 37 · Adv Chaskalson SC ·
called: You, in fact, called Cat Matlala. You called him at 10:34:40
Day 37 · Adv Chaskalson SC ·
See all 5 claims →
●
2 January 2025
Brown Mogotsi forwarded the Minister's 31 December 2024 disbandment letter for the PKTT to Vusimuzi Matlala on 2 January 2025, sharing classified information about the PKTT with a civilian contractor.
possession of letter: the 2 n d Brown Mogotsi has the letter
Day 3 · Lt Gen Mkhwanazi ·
sent letter to: he sends this letter to Cat Matlala
Day 3 · Lt Gen Mkhwanazi ·
See all 5 claims →
●
March 2025
By early March 2025, Matlala became aware that the SAPS Medicare 24 contract was heading for cancellation, prompting communication with Carrim and Mogotsi. The formal cancellation followed on 13 May 2025.
awareness of: Brown already knew
Day 73 · Mr Carrim ·
awareness of: it seems like Mr Matlala then picked up that this message he already received from Mr Mogotsi in March
Day 73 · Mr Carrim ·
See all 4 claims →
order between these two not established
●
3 March 2025
Suleiman Carrim underwent an eye operation on 3 March 2025, later citing it as grounds for medical inability to attend Commission hearings.
occurred on: he has been to an eye operation on the 3rd of March
Day 73 · Mr Khumalo (Nkosana Khumalo) ·
occurred on: he has to go for a second operation which is scheduled for tomorrow, the 10th of March
Day 73 · Mr Khumalo (Nkosana Khumalo) ·
●
2025-07-14 – 2025-07-17
The Commission presented geolocation data challenging Carrim's account of his movements, which bears on his claimed medical incapacity.
stated purpose: the point of putting up the evidence on the movements is not to disprove any diagnosis
Day 147 · Adv Hassim SC ·
stated purpose: not to use it to challenge the clinical findings of a treating doctor
Day 147 · Adv Hassim SC ·
See all 5 claims →
●
23 July 2025
A WhatsApp message dated 23 July 2025 at 20:14 from a number identified as Brown Mogotsi was sent to Mkhwanazi, followed by a three-minute call the same evening relating to the operation.
duration: Malcolm X calls me for three minutes.
Day 168 · Doctor Lebeya ·
subject matter: that was conversation relating to the operation.
Day 168 · Doctor Lebeya ·
See all 7 claims →
◆
2025-07-29 – 2025-08-06
The Evidence Leader provided a specialist's name to Mr Carrim's representatives, who forwarded it to the family and doctor. The Commission heard nothing from the attorneys and requested a response on consent to an independent medical evaluation.
provided specialist name to: We provided the name of such a specialist to Mr Carrim's representatives on the day after the ruling
Day 159 · Adv Hassim SC ·
response received: we received a response from Mr Carrim's attorney saying that they had forwarded that information to the family and to the treating doctor
Day 159 · Adv Hassim SC ·
See all 5 claims →
●
2025-09-10 – 2025-09-12
Mogotsi travelled to Kenya on 10–12 September 2025 to investigate allegations that Lt-Gen Mkhwanazi was a CIA operative, meeting contacts and reporting back.
departure date: I left to Kenya on the 10th of September 2025.
Day 35 · Brown Mogotsi ·
return date: I returned back from Kenya on the 12th of September 2025.
Day 35 · Brown Mogotsi ·
See all 4 claims →
●
December 2025
Advocate Johnson alleged he and Ms Ramsamy were manipulated by Binang, potentially affecting the inquiry's proceedings.
believed: I cannot shy away from there might have been a hidden hand in how this played itself out and what was given to me and how it was given to me.
Day 149 · Advocate Johnson ·
said: You and I, we were played against each other by Binang
Day 154 · Ms Ramsamy ·
See all 3 claims →
●
2026
The Commission issued rulings on procedural matters, including Carrim's postponement application, and made them available via its website and the media.
condition: about an open session here, that will depend on the ruling to be made in the application by Mr Carrim
Day 146 · Chairperson ·
status: there is still to be a ruling on that
Day 146 · Chairperson ·
See all 21 claims →
order between these two not established
●
2026
The Commission examined the management of Carrim's businesses, including the role of his PA, wife, and son, and outstanding financial statements and auditor information.
stated intention: he promised or undertook to furnish that information
Day 147 · Chairperson ·
status: this information continuing to be outstanding and not being furnished
Day 147 · Chairperson ·
See all 8 claims →
order between these two not established
●
9 March 2026
Brown Mogotsi filed an application for the recusal of Chief Evidence Leader Advocate Chaskalson on 9 March 2026, alleging improper pressure was placed on him to implicate Carrim. The application was heard and denied.
subject matter: We are meant to be dealing on the application of Mr Mogotsi for the recusal of an Evidence Leader
Day 109 · Advocate Hassim SC ·
applicant: application that is being brought by Mr Oupa Brown Mogotsi
Day 109 · Advocate Mohomane ·
See all 8 claims →
●
April 2026
Carrim sought to postpone his testimony, citing medical incapacity. The Commission challenged his movements and medical evidence, leading to a ruling that Carrim must appear and testify on 14 August 2026.
characterisation: you are bringing an application for a deferral of Mr Carrim's evidence to an undetermined date
Day 147 · Adv Baloyi SC ·
case: the question whether Mr Carrim's movements show a pattern that is at odds with what we have been told, that is central to the Evidence Leader's case
Day 147 · Chairperson ·
See all 7 claims →
●
14 August 2026
Mr Carrim did not appear on 14 August 2026 despite a ruling that he must. Evidence leader Adv Baloyi SC placed on the record that there was no basis to treat him as properly excused, no satisfactory explanation for the non-appearance, and that the condition prescribed as the basis for excusing him had not been complied with. Counsel for Mr Carrim (Mr Premhid) put the contrary position that his client was cooperating and was not running away from accountability.
contents: that gives you the state of Mr Carrim
Day 159 · Mr Premhid ·
requirement: Mr Carrim is required to appear and to testify today
Day 159 · Adv Hassim SC ·
See all 42 claims →
order between these two not established
●
14 August 2026
The basis on which Mr Carrim could be excused from appearing was an independent medical assessment. The Chairperson recorded that Mr Carrim was resisting being examined by an independent practitioner, had refused that it be done, and had instead offered his own specialists. Counsel for Mr Carrim described an alternative mechanism his side had proactively offered and undertook to cooperate if it were used.
condition for appearance: he may only not appear today on the basis of an independent medical assessment
Day 159 · Adv Hassim SC ·
resisting examination: Mr Carrim is resisting, strenuously so, to be examined by somebody who can actually challenge those reports
Day 159 · Chairperson ·
See all 7 claims →
order between these two not established
●
14 August 2026
The Chairperson stated that the Commission could not force Mr Carrim to appear, that this was the end of the road as far as having him before the Commission was concerned, and excused him. He also noted that Mr Carrim could take the Commission's decision on review, and that any defences to the criminal process were for Mr Carrim to raise there. A witness central to the SC0007 loan chain therefore leaves the Commission's reach without having been examined on it.
compulsion status: We cannot force him
Day 159 · Chairperson ·
has: Whether he has defences to that, that is something for him to raise in that criminal process
Day 159 · Chairperson ·
See all 5 claims →
1 contradiction linked to this scheme
◎ Likely — AI-assisted, cited◆ Cross-witness
KNN-d0238013de6c
Mogotsi–Matlala call and message log (pages 63 et seq.)
Same call's duration stated as three minutes vs 58 seconds; both cannot be true of the same call.
Day 168Doctor Lebeya“Malcolm X calls me for three minutes.”
Day 128General Mosikili“the duration of the call was for 58 seconds”