Carrim / Mogotsi / Matlala loan chain + ANC event payments
The allegation. According to evidence before the commission, a businessman, Mr Carrim, put millions of rands into the business of police contractor Mr Vusimuzi "Cat" Matlala, and money flowed out again — including to African National Congress events. Mr Brown Mogotsi testified that he was aware Carrim was an investor in the contract or tender awarded to Matlala by the South African Police Service. Carrim testified that his investment was R10 million "and nothing more"; Adv Chaskalson SC put to him that he advanced 10 million and would receive a return of an additional 10 million. Lieutenant General Khumalo testified that Matlala's payments were sometimes for expenses related to ANC events and for the benefit of delegates, and that Carrim appeared to be paid by Matlala. Mogotsi said Matlala assisted with funding transport, entertainment and accommodation for ANC members attending an ANC celebration in Cape Town.
How it allegedly worked. The money moved through companies rather than directly between people. A document records outgoing payments from Tameez Investments to Carrim and Mogotsi, and confirms Carrim as that company's bankcard holder. Carrim testified that Tameez "lent money to Mr Matlala via Ziggy". Adv Baloyi SC referred to a R10 million Ziggy payment and put to Carrim that he had advanced a loan to Matlala. Repayment then stalled. Carrim testified that Matlala owed him money and that he pressed him continuously for his monies. A message read into evidence shows Matlala following up with Carrim about "payment" on 30 January 2025. Carrim said Mogotsi already knew the SAPS contract was ending, and that Matlala picked this up from Mogotsi.
Who is named. The central figures are Carrim, Matlala and Mogotsi. Matlala appeared before the commission, where Adv Sello SC asked him about "the loan advanced by Mr Karim to you" and put to him that a Regulation 10(6) notice required him to address his involvement in the loan or funding agreement with Carrim. Mogotsi's role is contested. In a recusal application he brought against the evidence leader, Adv Chaskalson SC categorically denied inviting Mogotsi to give false evidence against Carrim, or suggesting he would be shielded from adverse findings.
Conduct alleged to be unlawful. Mr O'Sullivan told the commission he regarded the dealings as "part of the generally corrupt relationship". Carrim testified that other invoices were paid which were not disclosed to him, and that he remained owed money. Much remains untested. The chairperson said information Carrim had undertaken to furnish remained outstanding, and Adv Hassim SC said companies linked to him do business in hundreds of millions of rands. The chairperson said Carrim had refused an independent medical assessment, that the commission could not force him, and that this was the end of the road. Carrim's counsel, Mr Premhid, said a mechanism had been proactively offered and that they would cooperate.
The commission has not yet made findings. This overview summarises what was alleged in evidence; each number opens the claim it rests on.