Tshwane Security Tender Interference Network
The allegation. Security at City of Tshwane sites is largely bought in from private companies. Commissioner Spies testified that the City runs a hybrid model combining in-sourced guards with contracted private security firms, and Commissioner Bolhuis testified that the City appointed 22 security service providers through Tender TMPD02-2016.17. Witnesses said the Tshwane Municipal Police Department owns the security tender and helps write the bid specifications. Before the commission are allegations that this process was influenced from the inside — that lists of bidders' names moved between officials, and that one firm, Gubis 85 Security Solutions, was improperly allocated sites.
How it allegedly worked. The evidence runs along two strands. Deputy Commissioner Umashi Dlamini testified that on 9 March 2025 he sent Sergeant Fannie Nkosi names, saying "these are my bidders or my companies", and that on 18 March a message came back with "the list of preferred people". Adv Chaskalson SC put to him that he had already told Nkosi which bidders a man called Nico had assisted, naming Ngaphesheya and Elshadai, and that on 25 March 2025 he sent Nkosi a dropped bid evaluation committee report. Counsel told the commission that two of the seven ultimately successful bidders were Ngaphesheya and Elshadai. On the ground, a witness testified that Herman Segolela had already arranged for Gubis 85 to deploy at water sites over 30 and 31 December 2024, the Water and Sanitation department having promised the company it would start work. Bolhuis testified that Inspector Lebogang Andrew Phiri then signed notification letters allocating 40 sites to Gubis 85 between January and February 2025.
Who is named. Dlamini sits at the centre of this evidence and has been suspended. Commissioner Spies testified that the suspension followed his name coming up at the commission, and General Mosikili put the suspension to him. Dlamini denied wrongdoing. He testified that he had never received any payment or benefit from Nkosi, directly or indirectly, and that he had no interest in the company. He described his contact with Nkosi as frequent and natural, "as it will be between the brothers". Counsel put to him that on 27 March 2025 he told Gubis representatives to go back where they had started, that "Mfowethu is the only gateway", and that they could not use the back door.
Conduct alleged to be unlawful. The chairperson put to Commissioner Faro that the TMPD has a role in bid specification but not in bid evaluation or adjudication, and Faro said the department should not form part of supply chain management where it is the user. Commissioner Spies testified that there were allegations to investigate against Phiri for issuing written instructions to Gubis 85 to deploy ad hoc guards, "way beyond his mandate", and Bolhuis gave his view that the company was improperly allocated sites. Counsel put to witnesses that Gubis knew the City had expressly told it that it might not provide services from 1 July 2025.
The commission has not yet made findings. This overview summarises what was alleged in evidence; each number opens the claim it rests on.