WhatTheySaid.co.zaThe Madlanga Commission record, in plain language
SC0012

Hillbrow theft of precious stones

The allegation. Witnesses told the Madlanga Commission that officers of the Ekurhuleni Metropolitan Police Department (EMPD) posed as Hawks investigators to rob a Johannesburg man of a valuable consignment of stones. EMPD chief Isaac Jabulani Mapiyeye described the matter as a theft of precious stones while impersonating Hawks police officers, which took place in Hillbrow. He said the officers gained access to the complainant's property in Killarney, Johannesburg, under false pretences, claiming they were there to investigate lithium smuggling, and then robbed him of 54 kilograms of semi-precious stones. Commissioner Revo Spies testified that the stones were sugilite, "apparently a very expensive precious stone", and that to his knowledge they have never been recovered. The sum put on the loss was R45 million. The matter is recorded under case number 797/03/2023.

How it allegedly worked. Mapiyeye testified that at least two of three officers were involved — one of the three was not part of it — and that the officers concerned reported directly to Brigadier Mkhwanazi. "Our officers they went beyond our area of jurisdiction into Johannesburg, they have robbed someone about this precious stones," he said. He became aware of the case when a letter of demand was served on him in August 2023. On 15 August 2023, he testified, he delivered to the City Manager a letter of intent to institute proceedings regarding "the precious stones theft allegedly committed by members of EMPD". Two days later, Dr Imogen Mashazi, the City Manager, called a meeting and placed him on 30 days' leave. He said she told him she had decided he would take special leave with immediate effect, then corrected herself and said she was suspending him. Counsel put to the commission that the City of Ekurhuleni now faces a potential claim of R45 million in damages.

Who is named. Counsel asked Mashazi whether she had seen the letter of demand concerning alleged theft of precious stones by EMPD members reporting to Brigadier Mkhwanazi. At the Independent Police Investigative Directorate, Mr Keefelakae testified that the matter is with IPID, and Ms Nomsa Puriti Masuku testified that she was involved in the investigation and is the lead investigator. Lieutenant General Godfrey Lebeya testified that he assigned two senior managers to respond to "Hawks' impersonators", and referred to the matter under CAS number 797/3/2023. Mr Gregory Loftus testified that he was charged with impersonating a policeman.

Conduct alleged to be unlawful. Counsel put to a witness that the officers "robbed that person of precious stones". Keefelakae testified that IPID classified the matter under section 28(1)(g), "which is corruption", because of "the manner in which it happened, there was some kind of misrepresentation in the process". Loftus testified that it was implied that he had said he was still presently a captain in the police. On the leave decision, counsel put Mashazi's stated reason: that Mapiyeye was placed on special leave so that he could "clear your head, rest and come back neutral and with no biasness".

The commission has not yet made findings. This overview summarises what was alleged in evidence; each number opens the claim it rests on.

5 events0 contradictionsR45,000,000
People in this scheme
Dr Imogen Mashazi5Lieutenant General Godfrey Lebeya3Jabulani Isaac Mapiyeye2Nomsa Puriti Masuku2Gregory Loftus1Malcolm X (person referenced)1Commissioner Julius Mkhwanazi (suspended EMPD/Metr1
Timeline of events
✗
March 2023
EMPD officers impersonating Hawks police officers stole approximately R45 million worth of sugilite precious stones from a complainant's property in Killarney, Johannesburg. The officers gained access under false pretences. The stones were never recovered. Officers were reporting to Brigadier Julius Mkhwanazi.
case type: theft of precious stones impersonating Hawks police officers
Day 28 · Isaac Jabulani Mapiyeye ·
location: which took place in Hillbrow
Day 28 · Isaac Jabulani Mapiyeye ·
See all 21 claims →
order between these two not established
●
March 2023
The theft and Hawks impersonation was formally reported and a case opened at Hillbrow police station under case number 797/03/2023.
case number: case number 797/03/2023
Day 28 · Isaac Jabulani Mapiyeye ·
cas number: Hillbrow 797, I think, 03/23
Day 60 · Adv Baloyi SC ·
See all 3 claims →
★
April 2023
IPID assigned the precious stones investigation to senior investigator Nomsa Masuku under section 28(1)(g) of the IPID Act, classifying it as corruption due to the misrepresentation used to gain access.
falls under section 28 1 subsection: That one would fall under section 28(1)(g), which is corruption
Day 58 · Mr Keefelakae ·
reason for classification as corruption: the manner in which it happened, there was some kind of misrepresentation in the process
Day 58 · Mr Keefelakae ·
See all 8 claims →
◆
15 August 2023
Chief Mapiyeye delivered a letter of intent to City Manager Dr Mashazi on 15 August 2023, formally notifying him of intention to institute legal proceedings regarding the precious stones theft and the involvement of EMPD officers reporting to Brigadier Mkhwanazi.
delivered letter of intent on: On the 15th of August I delivered to the City Manager the letter of intent to institute proceedings regarding the precious stones theft allegedly committed by members of EMPD who were reporting direct
Day 28 · Isaac Jabulani Mapiyeye ·
subject: the letter of intent to institute proceedings regarding the precious stones theft allegedly committed by members of EMPD who were reporting directly to Brigadier Mkhwanazi.
Day 28 · Isaac Jabulani Mapiyeye ·
See all 4 claims →
◆
17 August 2023
Two days after receiving Mapiyeye's precious stones letter of intent, City Manager Dr Mashazi placed Chief Mapiyeye on special leave with immediate effect, citing the need for him to "clear his head and become neutral." The timing — 48 hours after Mapiyeye formally raised the theft — is a central allegation of the scheme.
suspended mapiyeye: She immediately corrected herself and told me that she was actually suspending me with immediate effect.
Day 28 · Isaac Jabulani Mapiyeye ·
decided mapiyeye take special leave: she stated that she had decided that I shall take special leave with immediate effect
Day 28 · Isaac Jabulani Mapiyeye ·
See all 7 claims →