WhatTheySaid.co.zaThe Madlanga Commission record, in plain language
SC0002

Tembisa Hospital extraction scheme

The allegation. A media article read into evidence described a "nearly R3-billion extraction scheme" at Tembisa Hospital. The commission also heard that the scandal was linked to a killing. Major General Senona testified that he heard on the radio, while travelling to work, of "a whistleblower who was murdered for exposing corruption at Tembisa Hospital", and that the murder of Ms Babita Deokaran was investigated by the Johannesburg Serious Organised Crime unit. Lieutenant General Shibiri testified that when the news of Ms Deokaran's death broke he had a full report, and that "it was indicated that the murder is about 200 million Tembisa tender". He testified that "the suspects were arrested for the murder, not for the tender".

How it allegedly worked. The evidence before the commission concerned mainly how the Tembisa matter was investigated and what it was called. Advocate Johnson testified that the matter had been referred by the Special Investigating Unit to the Directorate for Priority Crime Investigation around 2020, that "all of it lies within the ambit of the DPCI", and that this included the question whether Mr Morgan Maumela is involved. He testified that the file had also been written up as a case study for the Financial Action Task Force, subject to a confidentiality agreement. A second strand concerns naming. Counsel put to witnesses notes attributed to Mpangase recording "Police contract = for SAPS tender Tembisa Hospital". Advocate Ramsamy testified that Johnson had referred to the Medicare24 matter as the SAPS contract or Tembisa contract, and that she only became aware on 13 May 2025 that the SAPS/Tembisa contract was in fact the Medicare24 matter. Johnson was also asked why the Investigative Directorate Against Corruption was not doing anything about the Tembisa hospital matter.

Who is named. Counsel put to Lieutenant General Shibiri that by 2021/2022 it was publicly known that Mr Vusimuzi "Cat" Matlala was implicated in the Tembisa hospital tender fraud, and he answered "Yes", while testifying that he did not see it in 2022. A News24 report placed before the commission said an investigation into the award of a multi-million rand contract to a company owned by "Tembisa Hospital tenderpreneur Vusi Matlala" had uncovered several irregularities. Mr Brown Mogotsi testified that he saw on the news that Alu Construction was part of the consortium. Advocate Johnson named Maumela as a person whose involvement still had to be established.

Conduct alleged to be unlawful. The allegations before the commission are of fraud and corruption in the award of hospital and related SAPS contracts, described in a document read into evidence as a "nearly R3-billion extraction scheme" at Tembisa Hospital, and put by counsel as "the Tembisa hospital's tender fraud". Senona testified that a whistleblower was murdered for exposing corruption at the hospital. Against parts of this account, Ms Ramsamy testified that the documents she provided did not relate to Tembisa and were "just titled that", and Shibiri testified that the arrests were for the murder, not for the tender.

The commission has not yet made findings. This overview summarises what was alleged in evidence; each number opens the claim it rests on.

7 events0 contradictionsR3,000,000,000
Tembisa township, Gauteng
Tembisa township, Gauteng — where Tembisa Hospital serves more than 800,000 residents. R3 billion in PPE tenders was allegedly looted here during the pandemic. Joperd / Wikimedia Commons · CC BY 2.0
People in this scheme
Maj-Gen Senona6Advocate Johnson6Advocate Ramsamy4Advocate Sesi Baloyi, SC3Mr Vusimuzi 'Cat' Matlala2Babita Deokaran1Nomsa Puriti Masuku1
Timeline of events
★
2007
IPID investigator Nomsa Masuku transferred to the Tembisa cluster around 2007. She later testified about the cluster's operations at the Madlanga Commission.
moved to: I moved to Tembisa cluster, whereby I stayed there until 2010, but when I was at – no, I joined Tembisa in 2010 until 2013
Day 58 · Ms Masuku ·
●
17 August 2021
Babita Deokaran, who was investigating the Tembisa Hospital procurement fraud, was murdered on 17 August 2021. Her death is directly tied to the corruption scheme she was exposing.
mentioned in: the murder of Babita Deokaran
Day 5 · Lieutenant General Masemola ·
investigation subject at time of murder: it was the award of that contract that Babita Deokaran was investigating when she was murdered?
Day 36 · Adv Chaskalson SC ·
See all 17 claims →
●
13 February 2023
On 13 February 2023, Witness F sent Mr Msibi a YouTube video link titled 'Watch Tembisa Tender Tycoon, his mama cat and their brazen blue'. The video remains publicly available at https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=unbyMV32l8c — independent confirmation that the scheme was circulating in public discussion by early 2023.
action: on the 13th of February, you sent to Mr Msibi a link to a YouTube video which says: 'Watch Tembisa Tender Tycoon, his mama cat and their brazen blue light brigade'
Day 53 · Adv Chaskalson SC ·
●
October 2023
A media article in October 2023 exposed the relationship between Matlala and the Tembisa Hospital corruption scandal, linking the two schemes.
content: expose a questionable relationship between Matlala, a businessman implicated in the Tembisa Hospital corruption scandal
Day 48 · Adv Hassim SC ·
alleged conduct: talking about his alleged role in Mamelodi Hospital, Tembisa Hospital
Day 179 · lengthy article about Mr Matlala's history ·
See all 3 claims →
Position on the timeline not established by the record
≡
undated
A lucrative procurement contract at Tembisa Hospital was awarded to a consortium comprising Maumela and Matlala, later investigated by whistleblower Babita Deokaran.
contract award: that was awarded a lucrative contract at Tembisa Hospital?
Day 36 · Adv Chaskalson SC ·
membership in consortium: Yes, I saw that on the news, that is correct.
Day 36 · Brown Mogotsi ·
See all 16 claims →
⚡
undated
Suspects were arrested in connection with the murder of Babita Deokaran. The charges were for murder, not the underlying tender fraud.
action taken: Suspects were arrested
Day 75 · Lieutenant General Shibiri ·
action taken: I knew for sure that we arrested the suspect of the murder.
Day 75 · Lieutenant General Shibiri ·
See all 3 claims →
●
undated
A News24 article investigated and published the awarding of a multi-million rand procurement contract at Tembisa Hospital to a company linked to a tenderpreneur.
content: This follows after an investigation into awarding of this multi-million rand contract to a company owned by a Tembisa Hospital tenderpreneur Vusi Matlala, uncovered several irregularities.
Day 9 · Lieutenant General Khumalo ·
question: A question was put to you whether or not IDAC is investigating, I will call it generally, the Tembisa Hospital matter
Day 150 · Adv Sello SC ·
See all 35 claims →