WhatTheySaid.co.zaThe Madlanga Commission record, in plain language

Mr. Shadrack Sibiya

Deputy National Commissioner
3,741 claims1 scheme(s)6 contradiction(s)Wikipedia ↗
Schemes linked
SC0001Matlala / SAPS Health Risk Management / Medicare 24 con
What the record shows (3,741 claims total — showing first 12)
role
Head of the DPCI, the National Head of the Directorate of Priority Crime Investigation
Day 1 · Lt Gen Mkhwanazi · CL0000358
action taken
received the submission
Day 1 · Lt Gen Mkhwanazi · CL0000605
recommendation
recommended the deployment of, or the continued deployment of this team and the funding thereof as well as the approval, recommendation for the approval of Lt Gen Khumalo to be a project manager for this team for the period 2024 to 2025
Day 1 · Lt Gen Mkhwanazi · CL0000606
decision
determination on what must happen to the dockets
Day 1 · Lt Gen Mkhwanazi · CL0001077
communication channel
written correspondence directed to his subordinate, which is the head of detectives, Lt-Gen Senthumule
Day 1 · Lt Gen Mkhwanazi · CL0001078
role
Deputy National Commissioner
Day 1 · Lt Gen Mkhwanazi · CL0001085
directive
instructing the Divisional Commissioner to ensure that the cases under investigation, or the instruction by the Minister of Police, the directive of the 31st of December which was issued by the Minister of Police, that this directive be implemented i
Day 1 · Lt Gen Mkhwanazi · CL0001087
directive
directing that the Divisional Commissioner of Crime Detection must engage with the Divisional Commissioner of Crime Intelligence
Day 1 · Lt Gen Mkhwanazi · CL0001088
directive
all the dockets should be directed to a specific place at National Office outside the KZN area
Day 1 · Lt Gen Mkhwanazi · CL0001089
directed
transfer the dockets to each other
Day 1 · Lt Gen Mkhwanazi · CL0001131
reports to
both of those entities, fall under General Sibiya
Day 1 · Lt Gen Mkhwanazi · CL0001132
directed
issued the instruction and he commanded those two entities
Day 1 · Lt Gen Mkhwanazi · CL0001133
Contradictions
◎ Likely
(cross-phrasing)
Same entity, same act on same implementation plan: one says did not change the name, other says did change it to own name.
◎ Likely
(cross-phrasing)
One claims he did not know (Feb-Apr) that no work was done; the other asserts he did know—directly opposing on same knowledge.
◎ Likely
(cross-phrasing)
Cannot both not have antelopes after Nov 2023 and have procured them after that same period.
◎ Likely
(cross-phrasing)
Same proposition: Claim A indicates agreement while Claim B explicitly states 'I do not agree'; cannot both be true.
◎ Likely
(cross-phrasing)
A asserts Sibiya instructed Nkosi to forward warrant to Matlala; B explicitly denies ever doing so—same act, direct contradiction.
◎ Likely
(cross-phrasing)
A denies a work relationship; B affirms having an official/work relationship with the same person—directly contradictory.