WhatTheySaid.co.zaThe Madlanga Commission record, in plain language
SC0023

Task-team killings procured by private interests (Durban)

The allegation. Witnesses told the Madlanga Commission that police task teams in KwaZulu-Natal have been involved in killings rather than arrests. Mr Len Barnabas John spoke of evidence of repeated involvement in extrajudicial killings of alleged criminals. Mr Fadiel Adams asked whether what was being described was a hit squad. Minister Senzo Mchunu testified that unmonitored task team operations resulting in grave human rights abuses were a subject of concern. Lieutenant General Khumalo said the team had investigated organised hits and contract killings, and Lieutenant Colonel Khumalo described people "brutally killed for nothing. Greedy for money, greedy for tenders".

How it allegedly worked. Lieutenant General Masemola described the anatomy of a contract killing: someone who wants another eliminated finds a hitman, procures a firearm, uses people to spot or track the victim, and payment follows. He also testified that hitmen were used by police for information purposes and collection. Lieutenant Colonel Govender told the commission that the eThekwini District Task Team, the eThekwini Infrastructure Task Team and the Majuba Task Team were all involved in shootings, the eThekwini district team often in contact shootings. Deputy Director John said he believed a task team had used a cash-in-transit incident to cover the killing of a taxi owner. A statement read into evidence described a shooting on 5 January 2023, recorded under Berea CAS in the Allan Subramoney matter: the deponent, from Crime Intelligence, was shot at by men with automatic rifles and hit several times; he collided with a stationary vehicle, the gunmen kept shooting, and he hid in a nearby building. He underwent several surgeries and still has a bullet lodged in his back.

Who is named. The central unit is the national task team investigating political-related cases in KZN, known to witnesses as the Political Killings Task Team, as Lt Gen Nhlanhla Mkhwanazi explained. A document attributed to Minister Bheki Cele described an integrated multidisciplinary task team of SAPS and the NPA investigating political killings in the province. Against the allegations stands the official account. A document before the commission records that the team has its origins in a concerted government response to political killings in KZN. Masemola testified it was formed because existing investigative units were ill-equipped for the sophisticated nature of political killings and organised crime; Lieutenant General Khumalo said it was established as such incidents increased; and Lieutenant General Sibiya testified that the team focused specifically on its political-killings mandate. Doctor Lebeya referred to a project handled with Organised Crime in Gauteng. Also named are the district teams identified by Govender.

Conduct alleged to be unlawful. The allegations amount to killings carried out outside any lawful process, with hitmen used as police sources and, in one account, a cash-in-transit incident used to disguise a murder. Mchunu pointed to unmonitored operations producing grave human rights abuses. Counsel, Adv Sello SC, put it to a witness that no task team is needed for such an act: "It is a killing. We know where the mandate resides."

The commission has not yet made findings. This overview summarises what was alleged in evidence; each number opens the claim it rests on.

People in this scheme
Deponent (DivCom: Crime Intelligence)9Hardy matter suspect (former Crime Intelligence of3
Timeline of events
●
5 January 2023
A statement from Allan Subramoney (read into the record on day 158) describes him driving his white Mercedes Benz when he was shot at by men with automatic rifles, shot multiple times, colliding into a stationary vehicle and hiding in a nearby building while the gunmen continued shooting. He states he underwent several surgeries, still has a bullet lodged in his back and remains in recovery. The statement identifies the suspects as travelling in a white Toyota Etios, names the driver as Bevan Loftus and the front-passenger shooter as Ryan Santos, described as a known gang member and a hitman for Loftus, with a third shooter in the back seat. The statement was commissioned on 2023-04-25. Its timing and authenticity are disputed on the record - Mr Gregory Loftus disputes the delay between the January shooting and the April commissioning, states "That is a lie", and asserts Bevan Loftus was at home that day; separate testimony alleges the statement was taken at a later stage, backdated, and fabricated (CL0178296, CL0178297, CL0178298, CL0178320-CL0178326).
occurred on: This pertains to Berea CAS which is January 2023
Day 158 · Advocate Sikhakhane SC ·
authored by: This is a statement from Allan Subramoney
Day 158 · Advocate Sikhakhane SC ·
See all 19 claims →