IDAC investigation and criminal prosecution of the Crime Intelligence Seven
The allegation. An affidavit by Lieutenant General Nhlanhla Mkhwanazi, read into evidence, alleged that the Investigative Directorate Against Corruption (IDAC) pursued a criminal case against Lieutenant General Dumisani Khumalo and other Crime Intelligence officials in furtherance of ongoing political interference at the police service. Colonel Brian Padayachee told the commission the same. Mr Nqola put the allegation of a well-coordinated attack by IDAC on Mkhwanazi, Khumalo and General Sehlahle Fannie Masemola to a witness, and counsel put that it looked as though a "hidden hand" was driving IDAC's investigations into Crime Intelligence and the PKTT. Advocate Andrea Johnson denied the allegations, testifying that IDAC was investigating Khumalo in his capacity as Divisional Commissioner of Crime Intelligence for alleged unlawful conduct in the execution of his duties.
How it allegedly worked. Counsel put to witnesses how the matter reached IDAC. Adv Sello SC put that a complaint was forwarded to IDAC under section 27 of the NPA Act 32 of 1998 by a letter issued under the Minister's signature, and that the letter was wholly non-compliant with the very section it purported to invoke. He also put that IDAC used the mechanics of section 28(13) to conduct a full-blown investigation, which would render it unauthorised. Padayachee testified that IDAC requested case dockets from the police, and that he would step down rather than participate in something that started off unlawfully. Counsel put that IDAC took over the police investigation, including the Orlando and Langlaagte dockets, and went to the underlying docket instead of the complaint of a cover-up by Crime Intelligence. Johnson testified that IDAC received a section 27 referral from the SAPS Risk Audit Division.
Who is named. Johnson, who answered a Rule 3 notice arising from Mkhwanazi's allegations, is the official most often the subject of these claims. Khumalo and his co-accused — described by counsel as the seven people said to be involved in a scheme to capture Crime Intelligence — are the subjects of the prosecution. Mkhwanazi, Masemola and Padayachee gave or feature in the evidence. Advocate Serunye testified that IDAC drew on investigators seconded from the Directorate for Priority Crime Investigation.
Conduct alleged to be unlawful. Two sets of allegations run in opposite directions. Counsel and witnesses alleged political interference, an investigation begun unlawfully on a defective section 27 letter, and an unauthorised full-blown investigation under section 28(13). Johnson, by contrast, testified that the picture that emerged was that the appointment and installation of certain people in Crime Intelligence posts by Khumalo and his co-accused helped them strategically to access funding without following proper processes, and that IDAC had criminal investigations where supply chain management processes were circumvented. She denied the allegations made against IDAC.
The commission has not yet made findings. This overview summarises what was alleged in evidence; each number opens the claim it rests on.