WhatTheySaid.co.zaThe Madlanga Commission record, in plain language
SC0021

Carnilinx illicit tobacco intelligence-capture scheme

The allegation. According to evidence put before the commission, a senior police intelligence officer was allegedly aligned with one tobacco manufacturer, and state intelligence resources were allegedly turned on that company's rivals. Adv Chaskalson SC put to witnesses that Crime Intelligence resources were "being used to enable Carnilinx to take out a competitor or to raid a competitor in the name of the law", and that raids were conducted on the competitors of Carnilinx, the tobacco manufacturer, in the illegal tobacco industry. Adv Hassim SC put it that there have been consistent allegations that Carnilinx is itself engaged in illegal tobacco trading.

How it allegedly worked. The alleged channel was a running exchange of messages. Adv Chaskalson SC put to a witness that early chats showed Mr Sayed, described as the Carnilinx executive, and Major General Feroz Khan "enthusiastically applauding raids of illegal tobacco products that belong to competitors, either Protobac or Gold Leaf", and that Sayed had been given advance notice that SAPS was going to raid Protobac's bond store. Counsel said that raid left Protobac facing a R120 million fine for excise tax evasion. Benefits allegedly ran the other way. Adv Hassim SC put it that Khan asked Sayed to "work out a special price on the V8 M3", pressed for samples and prices, and reminded him not to forget his birthday present. Counsel further put that Sayed fed Khan business opportunities, including details of an IPID tender and a draft memorandum between Smada and Cyberia that Hassim characterised as "a thinly veiled kickback agreement".

Who is named. Khan sits at the centre of the evidence. Counsel put that he has held the rank of Major General since 1 September 2017, and a statement before the commission describes him as Head of Counter and Security Intelligence, responsible for national border security, counterintelligence and the vetting section. Sayed is named as the Carnilinx executive. Counsel also put that Sayed forwarded Khan a request from Mr Julius Malema, and that Khan, Sayed and Malema were to meet on 21 June 2025. In a document before the commission, Mr Adriano Mazzotti said Carnilinx had, "like any responsible corporate citizen", reported suspected unlawful conduct to the relevant authorities and had voluntarily approached the commission. Khan has not yet testified: Mr Vally told the commission that Khan was in hospital at the time, and that his doctor does not say he cannot testify.

Conduct alleged to be unlawful. The conduct alleged is the capture of police intelligence for a private commercial interest — tip-offs and raids that served a competitor's business, in exchange for benefits. Adv Chaskalson SC put to a witness that Carnilinx had acknowledged fraudulent schemes to defraud SARS of tobacco taxes. Adv Hassim SC put that an affidavit by Mazzotti dealt with the unlawful importation of tobacco under a false Swaziland pretext and with manufacturing cigarettes off the books. Mr O'Sullivan testified about associates of Khan allegedly involved in the illicit tobacco trade.

The commission has not yet made findings. This overview summarises what was alleged in evidence; each number opens the claim it rests on.

People in this scheme
Major General Feroz Khan107Mr Sayed13
Timeline of events
★
1 September 2017
General Feroz Khan was appointed as Major General and Component Head within Crime Intelligence, effective 1 September 2017.
promoted from: General Khan from Crime Intelligence was a Colonel in the Police, was promoted from the rank of a Colonel to a Major General
Day 3 · Lt Gen Mkhwanazi ·
promoted to: promoted from the rank of a Colonel to a Major General
Day 3 · Lt Gen Mkhwanazi ·
See all 8 claims →
≡
2020
Carnilinx entered into a settlement agreement with SARS to resolve past customs, excise, and tax non-compliance, accepting both criminal and civil liability.
dated: The settlement agreement that was concluded between Carnilinx and SARS was only concluded in 2020
Day 132 · Adv Hassim SC ·
stated purpose: it is hoped that this process will culminate in the company accepting criminal liability in a criminal court together with civil liability in respect of legislation administered by SARS
Day 132 · Adv Hassim SC ·
↓
2021
SAPS raided Protobac’s bond store, seizing 152×200 kg boxes of raw tobacco and 1,127×200 kg of cut rag valued at approximately R120 million, based on intelligence likely facilitated by General Khan.
activity: where he would conduct raids on the competitors of Carnilinx in the illegal tobacco industry
Day 133 · Adv Chaskalson SC ·
goods seized: 152 x 200kg boxes of raw tobacco
Day 133 · Adv Chaskalson SC ·
See all 6 claims →
order between these two not established
R
12 February 2021
General Khan asked Mr Sayed to arrange a special price on a V8 M3 vehicle and to urgently send samples and prices.
request: Send me samples and prices, please, ASAP. I am going to see someone tomorrow night who is the possible guy to make it happen.
Day 132 · Adv Hassim SC ·
request: Do not forget my birthday present …
Day 132 · Adv Hassim SC ·
See all 3 claims →
↓
10 May 2021
Several devices belonging to General Khan were seized, presumably as part of an investigation.
devices seized: there are several devices that were seized from General Khan on the 10 th of May
Day 132 · Adv Hassim SC ·
engagement occurred: nor he to my home
Day 150 · Advocate Johnson ·
See all 5 claims →
●
29 May 2021
General Khan sent Mr Sayed an image of his spare‑parts business, Magic Moto Spares, confirming his private business interest.
action taken: General Khan sends a picture of Magic Moto Spares, another one of his shops
Day 133 · Adv Hassim SC ·
action taken: another image of his store, Magic Moto Spares
Day 133 · Adv Hassim SC ·
●
14 June 2021
General Khan forwarded details of IPID tender bid number 02/2021/22, a letter to the Minister of Police, and a media statement to Mr Sayed.
sent: Mr Sayed sends General Khan a message
Day 132 · Adv Hassim SC ·
sent: Mr Sayed sends General Khan details of an IPID tender, bid number 02/2021/22 with a closing date of 2nd July 2021
Day 132 · Adv Hassim SC ·
See all 3 claims →
≡
26 July 2021
In WhatsApp messages, Mr Sayed and General Khan negotiated fee split terms (one-third each) for a draft MOU between Smada and Cyberia, relating to a R280 million National Treasury contract.
stated intention: We have to conclude, as Pilot can easily resolve. Then we are good if he signs.
Day 132 · Adv Hassim SC ·
stated expectation: So we get 92.4 odd? 280. 30%.
Day 132 · Adv Hassim SC ·
See all 12 claims →
●
4 August 2021
General Khan sent Mr Sayed a copy of the Treasury letter recommending the appointment of Kaizer.
sent: General Khan sends Mr Vally a copy of the Treasury letter recommending the appointment of Kaizen MSD
Day 133 · Adv Hassim SC ·
●
2022
Khan was part of the eventual seizure of Protobac's bond store, indicating his involvement in enforcement actions against competitors.
involvement: General Khan was a part of that eventual seizure
Day 150 · Adv Sello SC ·
order between these two not established
●
2022
Khan was involved in the Lushaba matter, with lost items reported to him, and he was alerted to his interaction with Lushaba following a housebreaking incident.
shed light on: about the Lushaba matter
Day 152 · Mr Raphesu ·
shed light on: it has something to do with the reporting
Day 152 · Mr Raphesu ·
See all 4 claims →
order between these two not established
●
2022
Khan provided a statement in the Mokwele/Khumalo letter and was mentioned in the docket, indicating his role in internal SAPS communications.
mentioned in: In brackets you have Khan
Day 153 · the docket ·
provided statement in: I know he provided a statement in the Mokwele/Khumalo letter
Day 153 · Advocate Serunye ·
order between these two not established
●
2022
Khan placed the initial advertisement for a position, though he claimed no knowledge of a related letter.
placed: the initial advertisement, which was placed by General Khan
Day 153 · Advocate Serunye ·
knowledge: General Khan even said, well, I do not know anything about this letter
Day 153 · Advocate Khumalo SC ·
order between these two not established
●
2022
Khan was on leave or suspension, consulted with the team before serving summonses, and identified Els and Hlongwane as possible witnesses in the Project Diversion investigations.
employment status: because he was on leave
Day 154 · Advocate Johnson ·
consulted with: so that he can consult with the team.
Day 154 · Advocate Johnson ·
See all 4 claims →
order between these two not established
●
2022
Khan told that General Khumalo did not have top-secret clearance and was instructed to follow up on the vetting process.
told: General Khan told them that General Khumalo did not have top-secret clearance
Day 154 · Mr Perumal ·
instructed to: he, General Khan, should follow up on the vetting process of General Khumalo
Day 154 · Mr Perumal ·
See all 23 claims →
order between these two not established
●
2022
Khan becomes important to Project Diversion investigations, though he had issues with SAPS management and was only speaking about his own issues.
stated view: Mr Perumal stated that Khan becomes very important to the Project Diversion investigations
Day 154 · Mr Perumal ·
employment status: there was a lot of talk about him being on sick leave or suspension
Day 154 · Ms Ramsamy ·
See all 4 claims →
order between these two not established
●
2022
Khan had influence on how certain matters progressed, particularly regarding the serving of summonses on NasCom.
said: Mr Khan said that they have to be served on the NasCom, being General Masemola
Day 154 · Feroz Khan ·
influence: I do believe that he had influence on these matters and how they progressed
Day 154 · Ms Ramsamy ·
order between these two not established
●
August 2022
Khan requested a favour from Sayed regarding suspicions that he is being investigated by the Hawks, indicating his concern about internal plotting.
action taken: an affidavit was taken for that matter
Day 149 · Advocate Johnson ·
intention: he wants to know who is plotting against him
Day 150 · Advocate Khumalo SC ·
See all 4 claims →
●
15 June 2025
Mr Sayed forwarded a request from Mr Malema to General Khan asking for the complaint details (case number Sandton 79/07/2019) about VBS Bank fraud.
action taken: a series of attempts and forwarded messages saying there is this opportunity here, there is that opportunity there
Day 132 · Adv Hassim SC ·
action taken: Mr Sayed sends General Khan a picture of a 911 Turbo Porsche
Day 133 · Adv Hassim SC ·
See all 6 claims →
◎
21 June 2025
General Khan met with Mr Sayed and Mr Malema at a location to discuss parliamentary questions and the Sandton case information.
met: General Khan, Mr Sayed and Mr Malema were going to meet
Day 134 · Adv Chaskalson SC ·
met: General Khan, Mr Sayed and Mr Malema were going to meet
Day 134 · Adv Chaskalson SC ·
See all 4 claims →
●
28 September 2026
General Khan was subpoenaed to give evidence before the commission on 28 September 2026 but did not appear, citing medical inability; the commission heard submissions that he was not continuously hospitalised, could appear remotely, and that his non-compliance should be referred to the NPA.
subject matter: there is a subpoena in place for General Khan's evidence to begin today
Day 179 · Adv Hassim SC ·
stated intention: Mr Khan wants time, wants a month, to prepare
Day 179 · Chairperson ·
See all 40 claims →