WhatTheySaid.co.zaThe Madlanga Commission record, in plain language
SC0020

EMPD City Manager protection and obstruction of discipline

The allegation. Witnesses told the commission that senior Ekurhuleni Metro Police Department officers facing misconduct charges were shielded from discipline by the top of the City. Chief Isaac Jabulani Mapiyeye testified that charges were never filed "due to the interference by the City Manager, Doctor Mashazi". Commissioner Revo Spies testified that such officers "were properly protected, does not matter what I say or do", with "the protection of the City Manager, the Head of HR, the Head of Legal", and that the department's integrity and standards function was "hiding in cupboards". Adv Khumalo SC put it to witnesses that EMPD leaves these matters to IPID and does nothing, promoting "a culture within EMPD of impunity".

How it allegedly worked. According to evidence before the commission, pressure came by telephone and through personnel decisions. In a statement read into evidence, Mr Xolani Nciza said that on 23 May 2023 he received a missed call from Dr Imogen Mashazi, who was "virulent, aggressive", accused him of targeting Brigadier Mkhwanazi and said she would tell the HR head that the brigadier was coming back to work. Mapiyeye testified that Mashazi accused him and Spies of being "the main drivers behind these charges" and then suspended him; a letter put to Spies placed Mapiyeye on special leave so that he could "come back neutral and with no biasness". Ms Linda Gxasheka testified that Mashazi asked why a hearing was still continuing and that "it was clear that you must stop this hearing". Mashazi testified that she herself appointed Commissioner Julius Mkhwanazi to act as Chief of Police — the post that, she said, held the authority to discipline him.

Who is named. Mashazi, as City Manager, is at the centre of the claims. Mapiyeye and Spies are the officers who say charges were blocked, and Nciza described himself as custodian of the municipality's disciplinary management processes. Mashazi gave a contrary account of her own position. She testified that when she tried in August 2024 to put a report on Mapiyeye's alleged sexual harassment misconduct to the mayoral committee, she was called in by the Mayor, the MMC for finance and "a guy called Absalom Budeli from ANC", told to stop the process, and urged to take special leave.

Conduct alleged to be unlawful. The core allegation is improper interference in disciplinary processes — stopping investigations and hearings, and sidelining those who pursued charges. Nciza testified that Mashazi stopped a 2017 investigation and halted a disciplinary hearing; Mashazi denied this, testifying: "I did not stop or interfere in the withdrawal of the investigation." Gxasheka's evidence included that Mashazi had never instructed her, in writing or in a meeting, not to discipline Commissioner Julius Mkhwanazi. Counsel put to Mashazi that Mapiyeye and Spies contended the acting appointments were irregular, and she said she accepted that. Mr Keefelakae testified that "this inaction signals a reluctance to enforce accountability", while Spies testified that staff would not object because they live in fear.

The commission has not yet made findings. This overview summarises what was alleged in evidence; each number opens the claim it rests on.

People in this scheme
Dr Imogen Mashazi51
Timeline of events
◆
2017
As City Manager, Dr Mashazi intervened to stop the CRM investigation and disciplinary hearing against Brigadier Mkhwanazi, providing no reason based on merits.
intervention status: Yes.
Day 31 · Mr Nciza ·
stopped investigation: When that came to Mashazi's attention, she then instructed that we can that investigation
Day 31 · Mr Nciza ·
See all 4 claims →
◆
23 May 2023
Dr Mashazi called Mr Nciza and Ms Gxasheka, shouting that Brigadier Mkhwanazi must return to work the next day and that she would ensure it.
called: I saw that on my WhatsApp I had a missed call from Doctor Mashazi, the city manager
Day 31 · Mr Nciza ·
called: Maybe after the two calls to me and Mapiyeye, Mashazi would have called her
Day 31 · Mr Nciza ·
See all 8 claims →
◆
June 2023
In a meeting, Dr Mashazi accused Chief Mapiyeye of persecuting Brigadier Mkhwanazi, threatened to suspend him, and placed him on special leave with immediate effect, claiming he needed to clear his head.
alleged statement to mapiyeye: she allege that you and Commissioner Spies are the main drivers behind these charges and you just want to persecute Brigadier Mkhwanazi
Day 28 · Isaac Jabulani Mapiyeye ·
threatened to suspend mapiyeye: threatened to suspend me with immediate effect.
Day 28 · Isaac Jabulani Mapiyeye ·
See all 7 claims →
◎
2023-08-17 – 2023-08-18
Dr Mashazi met with Chief Mapiyeye over two days, requesting him to produce a turnaround plan and asking the HOD to take minutes.
meeting date with chief mapiyeye: I indicated that I had a meeting with the Chief on the 16th
Day 41 · Doctor Mashazi ·
meeting topic with chief mapiyeye: the issues that I raised, it was about the dysfunctionality of the department.
Day 41 · Doctor Mashazi ·
See all 7 claims →
★
17 May 2024
Dr Mashazi appointed Brigadier Mkhwanazi as Acting Chief of Police for a period from 17 May 2024 to end of July 2025, an appointment later challenged as irregular.
appointer of: the appointment was made by myself
Day 42 · Doctor Mashazi ·
question period for acting appointments: from 17th May 2024 to the end of July 2025, do you recall appointing anyone to act as a chief, as an acting Chief of Police?
Day 42 · Adv Sello SC ·
See all 6 claims →
◆
August 2024
Dr Mashazi attempted to submit a report on Chief Mapiyeye's serious misconduct to the mayoral committee but was blocked by the Mayor and others, who instructed her to stop the process.
attempted submission to mayoral committee date: I tried again in August to submit the report to the mayoral committee
Day 42 · Doctor Mashazi ·
first submission status: The first time it was never even entertained
Day 42 · Doctor Mashazi ·
See all 13 claims →
Position on the timeline not established by the record
◆
unknown
Dr Mashazi gave instructions to stop the disciplinary hearing against Commissioner Mkhwanazi and settle the matter.
instruction: you never got an instruction from Doctor Mashazi not to discipline Commissioner Mkhwanazi? Whether in writing, whether in writing, whether in a meeting, Doctor Mashazi never instructed you not to disc
Day 69 · Ms Linda Gxasheka ·
asked: Why is ER continuing?
Day 69 · Ms Linda Gxasheka ·
See all 6 claims →
1 contradiction linked to this scheme
◎ Likely — AI-assisted, cited◆ Cross-witness
NLI-3ee0060e7f10
A says Mashazi instructed to stop the investigation; B says she did not stop or interfere in its withdrawal—directly contradictory.
Day 31Mr Nciza“When that came to Mashazi's attention, she then instructed that we can that investigation”
Day 41Doctor Mashazi“I did not stop or interfere in the withdrawal of the investigation”