Ministerial interference in police operations
The allegation. Witnesses told the commission that the Minister of Police, Mr Senzo Mchunu, crossed the line between political oversight of the police and the running of police operations. Counsel for the commission, Adv Motau SC, said the inquiry would examine whether the Minister interfered with sensitive police investigations and colluded with business people, including a murder accused, to disband the Political Killings Task Team based in KwaZulu-Natal. Those allegations, together with claims of corruption and criminal infiltration of law enforcement, were raised publicly by Lieutenant General Mkhwanazi on 6 July 2025. Mchunu was placed on special leave on 13 July 2025.
How it allegedly worked. According to evidence before the commission, the instrument was the ministerial letter. Lieutenant General Shadrach Sibiya testified that on 1 November 2024 Mchunu directed the SAPS Executive Committee to reconsider and review certain operational capabilities, specifically including the task team. A letter dated 31 December 2024, read into evidence and signed "Minister of Police, Mr ES Mchunu MP", stated that the team must be disestablished immediately. Lieutenant General Masemola testified that the abrupt directive disregarded ongoing investigations and amounted to what he considered irrational and inexplicable encroachment into operational issues and into the mandate of the National Commissioner. It was unusual, he said, for a Minister to involve himself in deciding who investigates which docket. Mchunu testified that his letter dealt with organisational placement and budget implications, and that he briefed the President on the dissolution.
Who is named. Mchunu is at the centre. Mkhwanazi testified that the Minister phoned the Umhlali station commander, asked to meet station management about a case against a competitor in the elections, and wanted that person arrested so he could not stand for the other party. Major General Gopaul testified that on 31 March 2025 Mchunu came to Umhlali police station, was found with ANC officials in the station commander's office, and demanded the docket and an explanation of why Mr Doeshiee Govender had not been arrested; the chairperson put that, according to the Minister, this was because the police were doing nothing. Mkhwanazi's affidavit records an allegation that IDAC pursued a criminal case against Lieutenant General Khumalo and other Crime Intelligence officials in furtherance of political interference. Ms Ramsamy testified that Mchunu's involvement seemed more than receiving updates on a complaint by Mr Adams.
Conduct alleged to be unlawful. The chairperson put to Masemola that the instruction fell outside the Minister's remit, straying onto operational and managerial matters, and was unlawful in effect. Adv Sello SC put that the directive letter was interference in the affairs of SAPS. Against that, Adv Motau SC put that a Minister cannot be criticised for intervening between his executives, and Masemola accepted that in principle a Minister can intervene. Mchunu's own account was that his letter dealt with organisational placement and budget implications.
The commission has not yet made findings. This overview summarises what was alleged in evidence; each number opens the claim it rests on.
