WhatTheySaid.co.zaThe Madlanga Commission record, in plain language
SC0018

Tshwane CFO vendor registry abuse

The allegation. At issue is how the City of Tshwane decided who was registered as a supplier and who got paid. Mr Mnisi, the city's chief financial officer, told the commission that suppliers were reporting challenges relating to vendor registration, that the city "could not account for our trade payables" and that there were "clearly not sufficient internal controls in place". Commissioner Faro, the chief of police, testified that all procurement processes are finalised by the CFO. Counsel put to Mnisi a message asking "can I have Bheki's vendor number at Tshwane?", and put that the request was for his brother's vendor number at the municipality.

How it allegedly worked. Payments ran through a chain the commission heard was weakly controlled. Mnisi testified that colleagues at the Tshwane Municipal Police Department would receive invoices, validate work done and assess whatever proof of evidence they had, then upload invoices for the creation of purchase orders. Mr Umashi Samson Dhlamini, a TMPD official, told the commission: "What we do, we increase the contract value so that we are able to process I mean those invoices." Mnisi testified that past conduct at the TMPD resulted in seven months' worth of invoices having been dealt with only in January. Counsel put that Mnisi was discussing payment issues between Tshwane and its service providers with Sergeant Fannie Nkosi, and put to him messages asking "Are you meeting with number 1, JS."

Who is named. Mnisi is the central figure. He testified that on 7 February 2025 he escalated a matter to Mr Tshukudu Malatji and copied Cain, and that he forwarded a letter to Nkosi; counsel put that he called Nkosi on 21 March 2025. Mr Johannes Madoda Sibanyoni, known as "Joe Ferrari", told the commission that Mnisi had used the appellation "Number One" in his testimony and that it was alleged this referred to him. In a statement read into evidence, Sibanyoni said he met Mnisi on one occasion, that there is no ongoing personal or business relationship between them, and that he has never had any financial dealings with Mnisi. Counsel also put a message from Mnisi to Mr Mashile, the Mpumalanga chief financial officer: "Let us meet 007 tonight after my meeting. It is urgent."

Conduct alleged to be unlawful. Adv Chaskalson SC put to a witness that "the CFO is committing to Sergeant Nkosi to do something which is unlawful in relation to a tender at Tshwane". Adv Khumalo SC put that the city cancelled the TMPD 2016-2017 tender because of an allegation that 50 bids went missing, and raised concern about "dishing out tenders where you are spending billions of rands". Mnisi said he had no formal substantive evidence proving what was being discussed, and testified that his security protection was removed roughly in December 2024. Faro said the city has a fraud line, and asked why those who come forward against fraud and corruption become targets.

The commission has not yet made findings. This overview summarises what was alleged in evidence; each number opens the claim it rests on.

People in this scheme
Mr Mnisi37Mr Mashile (Mpumalanga CFO; contact of suspended T2
Timeline of events
●
December 2024
TMPD officers Nkomo and Mabunda removed Mr Mnisi's security protection.
security removed: Roughly in December 2024, yes.
Day 94 · Mr Mnisi ·
security removed by: removal of your security by I think it was Officers Nkomo and Mabunda of the TNPD.
Day 94 · Advocate Chaskalson SC ·
See all 3 claims →
order between these two not established
◎
28 December 2024
A meeting occurred on the 28th of December 2024 where a recommendation was made regarding a tender. Mr Mnisi accepted that the recommendation was made at this meeting.
acceptance status: I accepted it at that, between December, January
Day 92 · Mr Mnisi ·
acceptance status: I had accepted and in December this happened
Day 92 · Mr Mnisi ·
See all 3 claims →
◆
7 February 2025
Mr Mnisi followed up and escalated a matter to Mr Tshukudu Malatji and Calvin, likely related to a tender issue.
action taken: I personally on the 7th follow up and make escalations
Day 92 · Mr Mnisi ·
action taken: I escalate that further immediately . I say, TMPD, I directed that matter to Mr Tshukudu Malatji, who was on the email. I then cc Cain, or I direct to Cain
Day 94 · Mr Mnisi ·
See all 3 claims →
●
5 March 2025
Mr Mnisi communicated with Deputy Commissioner Dhlamini, General Dlamini, and Sergeant Nkosi.
communicated with: Mr Mnisi and Deputy Commissioner Dhlamini communicated with each other on 5 March
Day 84 · Commissioner Spies ·
communicated with: You keep speaking to General Dlamini and Sergeant Nkosi about this
Day 93 · Advocate Baloyi SC ·
See all 3 claims →
●
21 March 2025
Mr Mnisi called Sergeant Nkosi and General Khumalo, and sent messages including weapons pictures and a personal message.
sent message to: I have sent the above to Bheki
Day 81 · Adv Chaskalson SC ·
sent message to: I thereafter forwarded a letter to Sergeant Nkosi
Day 92 · Mr Mnisi ·
See all 5 claims →
●
4 September 2025
Mr Mnisi was not present at the Bid Adjudication Committee meeting on 4 September 2025.
attendance status: I was not present at the B AC that set on the 4t h of September
Day 92 · Mr Mnisi ·
Position on the timeline not established by the record
●
undated
Mr Mnisi asked Sergeant Nkosi for the vendor number of Nkosi's brother's company, ostensibly to check compliance with the City's new vendor system.
content: What is his vendor number?
Day 81 · Adv Chaskalson SC ·
content: My brother, can I have Bheki's vendor number at Tshwane? Thanks, my guy.
Day 81 · Adv Chaskalson SC ·
See all 3 claims →
●
undated
Mr Mnisi asked about vendor 'JS' (Number 1) and expressed concern about meeting with that person.
stated question: his response was: 'Who my bro? Number 1, JS.'
Day 82 · Adv Chaskalson SC ·
stated question: he asked: 'Are you meeting with number 1, JS.'
Day 82 · Adv Chaskalson SC ·
See all 9 claims →
◎
undated
A meeting occurred regarding the Gubis payment, during which Mr Mnisi did not have Deputy Chief Dhlamini's contact details.
reason: for privacy and confidential reasons
Day 92 · Mr Mnisi ·
possession of: As at this point I did not have telephone details
Day 92 · Mr Mnisi ·
See all 6 claims →
●
undated
While driving, Sergeant Nkosi called Deputy Chief Dhlamini and gave the phone to Mr Mnisi, leading to Mr Mnisi discovering the relationship between them.
discovery time: Now when did you discover that Sergeant Nkosi had taken it upon himself?
Day 94 · Advocate Chaskalson SC ·
discovery circumstance: So I was driving, he went on a call, he called Deputy Chief Dhlamini, and he gave me the phone. That is when I identified that he had given him a call already
Day 94 · Mr Mnisi ·
◎
undated
Mr Mnisi sent a message to Mr Mashile arranging a meeting at '007' that night, indicating it was urgent.
message content: You will indicate.
Day 79 · Adv Chaskalson SC ·
message content: Let us meet 007 tonight after my meeting. It is urgent.
Day 79 · Adv Chaskalson SC ·
See all 3 claims →