WhatTheySaid.co.zaThe Madlanga Commission record, in plain language
SC0014

SAPS Medical Surveillance Contract Kickback Scheme

The allegation. At the centre of this matter is a contract between the South African Police Service and Medicare 24 Tshwane District (Pty) Ltd, a company belonging to Mr Vusimuzi "Cat" Matlala, for the medical screening of police officers and health risk management services over three years. Matlala told the commission his company was contracted by SAPS to provide health and risk-related services. Documents before the commission allege tender fraud by Matlala in relation to the R360 million contract between Medicare 24 and SAPS, and allege that the contract was unlawfully procured. An affidavit by General Matlou, read into evidence, records alleged procurement irregularities in the appointment of the service provider for health risk management services.

How it allegedly worked. Counsel put to Brigadier Matjeng that she received a total of R113 500 from Matlala between June 2019 and September 2021. She testified that she started in the relevant environment in October 2023, and counsel put to her that she was the section head from 16 October 2023. Counsel also put that the tender was advertised in January 2024 and awarded on 14 June 2024. In December 2024, counsel put to her, she asked Matlala for money and gave him an account number that was not her own; on 10 January 2025 she supplied the account number of Osizweni Meat Hyper. Three payments of R100 000 followed. Matjeng testified she never received that money, because Matlala owed a debt to Osizweni Butcher. She testified that she forwarded Matlala a name list of 140 members and a Lancet statement, and counsel put to her that she gave him a list of no-shows and telephoned a supplier over his certificate-of-fitness problem. Of that call she testified: "I think I overstepped there."

Who is named. Matlala, the owner of Medicare 24 Tshwane District, and Brigadier Matjeng, who testified about managing the SAPS medical surveillance and biological monitoring programme. Matjeng testified that she told her supervisor, General Manamela, that she knew Matlala and explained the nature of their relationship. An affidavit records that Minister Mcunu referred the Medicare 24 matter to SAPS Internal Audit Risk and Integrity Management. Ms Ramsamy testified that she only became aware on 13 May 2025 that what was called the SAPS or Tembisa contract was in fact the Medicare24 matter.

Conduct alleged to be unlawful. Documents before the commission allege tender fraud and the unlawful procurement of the R360 million SAPS contract, and an affidavit alleges procurement irregularities in appointing the service provider. Counsel put to a witness that SAPS cancelled that contract on grounds of fraud and corruption. The evidence about Matjeng goes to an alleged conflict of interest: payments and favours from a contractor whose work she oversaw. Her contrary account is that she disclosed the relationship and asked to be recused from the medical surveillance responsibility; counsel put to her that her superior told her not to recuse herself. She also testified she never received the money.

The commission has not yet made findings. This overview summarises what was alleged in evidence; each number opens the claim it rests on.

People in this scheme
Brigadier Matjeng52Mr Vusimuzi 'Cat' Matlala1
Timeline of events
R
June 2019
Brigadier Matjeng received a total of R113,500 from Vusimuzi Matlala in multiple payments from June 2019 to September 2021, characterized as gifts from a boyfriend.
received payments from: you have received from Mr Matlala a total of R113 500
Day 54 · Adv Baloyi SC ·
total payments received zar: you have received from Mr Matlala a total of R113 500
Day 54 · Adv Baloyi SC ·
●
September 2023
Brigadier Matjeng told Mr. Matlala about a bank account, according to her testimony.
told matlala about account: previously, I told him about this account that I was owing and could not settle the account.
Day 54 · Brigadier Matjeng ·
order between these two not established
●
September 2023
Brigadier Matjeng's car was burned down, which led to her needing vehicle finance and later asking Matlala for money.
stated belief: when I say, I told you Ka September, I am referring to September 2023, after my car was burned down, and I could not get a car.
Day 54 · Brigadier Matjeng ·
★
16 October 2023
Brigadier Matjeng assumed her position in the Component Criminal Record and Crime Scene Management, which included oversight of medical surveillance.
appointment date: That is 16 October 2023. Do you see that? You are the Section Head.
Day 54 · Adv Khumalo SC ·
role start date: That is 16 October 2023. Do you see that? You are the Section Head.
Day 54 · Adv Khumalo SC ·
See all 3 claims →
≡
January 2024
The SAPS Health Risk Management tender was advertised in January 2024.
advertisement date: the SAPS Health Risk Management tender was only advertised in January 2024
Day 53 · Adv Khumalo SC ·
order between these two not established
●
January 2024
Brigadier Matjeng stated she became aware of the request for quotation (RFQ) in January 2024.
awareness of rfq: you were aware that in January of 2024, a new RFQ was going out
Day 54 · Adv Khumalo SC ·
≡
14 June 2024
The SAPS Health Risk Management tender was awarded on 14 June 2024 to Medicare 24 Tshwane (Mr. Matlala's company).
award date: it was awarded in June, on the 14th of June 2024
Day 53 · Adv Khumalo SC ·
required: the notice required you, with regards to the SAPS contract awarded to Tshwane Medicare24, to explain the circumstances in which you came to submit a tender for the SAPS health risk management contract
Day 160 · Adv Sello SC ·
See all 5 claims →
◎
August 2024
In August 2024, Brigadier Matjeng and Mr. Matlala arranged a meeting.
arranged by: That is correct, Commissioner
Day 54 · Brigadier Matjeng ·
●
December 2024
Brigadier Matjeng asked Mr. Matlala for money and instructed him to use an account number that was not hers.
action: you are asking him for money in December
Day 54 · Adv Baloyi SC ·
action: you give him an account number which is not yours
Day 54 · Adv Baloyi SC ·
See all 3 claims →
R
January 2025
Mr. Matlala deposited R100,000 into the Osizweni Meat Hyper account, intended for Brigadier Matjeng but kept by Modiegi as debt repayment.
non receipt reason: I never received that money due to the debt that Matlala had with Osizweni Butcher.
Day 54 · Brigadier Matjeng ·
intended recipient: That is meant for you
Day 54 · Brigadier Matjeng ·
See all 3 claims →
order between these two not established
●
10 January 2025
Brigadier Matjeng sent the account number of Osizweni Meat Hyper to Mr. Matlala for payment.
responded with account number: you respond at 11:25 by saying: 'Good morning, Mr V.' And you provide then an account number of Osizweni Meat Hyper.
Day 54 · Adv Pooe ·
◎
17 January 2025
Brigadier Matjeng confirmed a meeting that took place on 17 Jan 2025, discussing medical surveillance authorization progress and delays.
discussion subject: we discussed medical surveillance authorization issued to the component CR & CSM, which were progressing at a very slow pace
Day 54 · Brigadier Matjeng ·
sent message: You sent a message to Mr Matlala at 10:15 confirming a meeting that was going to take place that afternoon.
Day 54 · Adv Pooe ·
See all 4 claims →
R
February 2025
A third payment was made to the Osizweni Meat Market account.
payment recipient: the third payment of 100 000 is made on this day to the Osizweni Meat Market.
Day 55 · Adv Pooe ·
order between these two not established
R
4 February 2025
Another R100,000 was paid into the Osizweni account by Matlala, also intended for Matjeng but kept by Modiegi.
purpose: He sent it to Osizweni Butcher to pay his debt.
Day 54 · Brigadier Matjeng ·
payment reason: He paid it into that account knowing very well that he is owing Osizweni.
Day 54 · Brigadier Matjeng ·
●
3 March 2025
Major General Manamela informed Brigadier Matjeng about complaints regarding the Lancet account and two follow-up appointments.
informed: I then informed my supervisor, Major General Mana mela, that I know Mr Matlala and explained the nature of our relationship
Day 54 · Brigadier Matjeng ·
informed: informed him that there was two follow-up appointments on 2024-08-26 to 2024- 08-27
Day 54 · Brigadier Matjeng ·
See all 3 claims →
◎
2025-03-10 – 2025-03-12
Brigadier Matjeng met with Mr. Matlala and/or Cat Matlala between 10 and 12 March 2025.
met: After the meeting.
Day 54 · Brigadier Matjeng ·
met: I definitely saw him in between
Day 55 · Brigadier Matjeng ·
See all 3 claims →
●
20 March 2025
Brigadier Matjeng requested medication (Ozempic) from Mr. Matlala and communicated location updates.
request for medication: you make a request for your medication
Day 55 · Adv Pooe ·
sent location to matlala: And then you send a location.
Day 55 · Adv Pooe ·
See all 4 claims →
◎
16 April 2025
A meeting was held on 16 April 2025 to discuss the medical surveillance roll-out for 2025-2026.
discussion subject: Medical surveillance roll out for 2025 to 2026
Day 54 · Brigadier Matjeng ·
◎
12 May 2025
Brigadier Matjeng was with Mr. Matlala on 12 May 2025.
was with: A day before, on the 12t h , I was with him
Day 55 · Brigadier Matjeng ·
order between these two not established
●
12 May 2025
Mr. Matlala sent a letter to SAPS alleging breach of contract on 12 May 2025; Brigadier Matjeng read it and felt sorry for him.
confirmed receipt of letter: Yes.
Day 55 · Brigadier Matjeng ·
emotional state after reading letter: I just felt sorry. Just felt sorry for him.
Day 55 · Brigadier Matjeng ·
See all 5 claims →
Position on the timeline not established by the record
●
unknown
Brigadier Matjeng disclosed her relationship with Mr. Matlala to Major General Manamela and asked if she should recuse herself from medical surveillance responsibility.
asked: I further asked if I should recuse myself from the responsibility of managing the medical surveillance and biological monitoring program
Day 54 · Brigadier Matjeng ·
disclosure of relationship to manamela: why did you disclose in paragraph 14 to Brigadier Manamela that you have a relationship with him
Day 54 · Adv Baloyi SC ·
See all 6 claims →
◆
unknown
Brigadier Matjeng asked Major General Manamela if she should recuse herself from managing the medical surveillance program due to her relationship with Matlala, but was told not to.
asked: I further asked if I should recuse myself from the responsibility of managing the medical surveillance and biological monitoring program
Day 54 · Brigadier Matjeng ·
instruction from superior: your superior said you must not recuse yourself from this contract because if there are challenges, you would have to deal with them.
Day 54 · Adv Baloyi SC ·
See all 5 claims →
●
unknown
Brigadier Matjeng approached a service provider to release Certificates of Fitness (COFs) for Matlala, which resolved both Matlala's and SAPS's issues; seen as overstepping her role.
action recollection: what comes into my mind is talking to the service provider regarding the COFs
Day 54 · Brigadier Matjeng ·
role in action: in what capacity were you then taking on what is essentially his issue with a service provider?
Day 54 · Adv Pooe ·
See all 8 claims →
●
unknown
Brigadier Matjeng provided Matlala with a list of members who did not attend medical surveillance appointments, enabling him to claim for them.
stated information to matlala: you tell him this is the list of no - shows.
Day 55 · Adv Baloyi SC ·
gave list to matlala: You gave Mr Matlala this list. Right?
Day 55 · Adv Baloyi SC ·
●
unknown
Brigadier Matjeng forwarded a list of 140 members' names to Mr. Matlala, likely for medical surveillance scheduling.
forwarded: forwarded him the name list of 140 members
Day 54 · Brigadier Matjeng ·
●
unknown
Brigadier Matjeng sent a statement of the Lancet account to Mr. Matlala to show the amounts owed.
sent: I sent him proof of the Lancet statement
Day 54 · Brigadier Matjeng ·
sent: I send it to him whereby there was a member's name as an account holder
Day 54 · Brigadier Matjeng ·
1 contradiction linked to this scheme
◎ Likely — AI-assisted, cited
NLI-c4ab873c3224
Same actor on same act: one says approaching the provider was overstepping/wrong, the other calls it the most plausible right move.
Day 54Brigadier Matjeng“I think I overstepped there. I was not supposed to approach the service provider.”
Day 54Brigadier Matjeng“the most plausible thing or what you have in your mind would have been to approach the service provider.”