WhatTheySaid.co.zaThe Madlanga Commission record, in plain language
SC0013

SAPS insider tipping-off and evidence compromise ring

The allegation. Evidence before the commission describes police officers allegedly serving the people they were meant to investigate. Lieutenant General Masemola testified about identifying senior SAPS officers who were associated with criminal syndicates, and about the apparent association of SAPS officials of various ranks with individuals under investigation. General Khumalo said his concern was the infiltration of SAPS at the highest level by syndicates. Mr Fadiel Adams told the commission that case information may be circulated within what he regards as an informal SAPS network or cabal, with the effect of protecting those themselves accused of corruption. An Internal Affairs Unit report read into the record described a SAPS member colluding with implicated JMPD officers to covertly obtain and disclose an investigator's personal information.

How it allegedly worked. A junior officer allegedly acted as the conduit. Mr Mnisi testified that Sergeant Fannie Nkosi sent him a list of entities on 11 March 2024. Counsel put to Nkosi that he retrieved a jet ski from the farm of Mr Vusimuzi 'Cat' Matlala in September 2024, and that he was in constant contact with Matlala on 4 and 5 December 2024, and again on 6 December 2024, the day Matlala's house was raided. Counsel also put that Nkosi reported a call at 06:30 on 16 December 2024 to come and see "number 1". Lieutenant General Shibiri said Nkosi forwarded him Matlala's new telephone number on 18 December 2024. Chat records read into evidence show Nkosi returning a signed document to Mr Jacob on 9 February 2025 and forwarding it to Mr Msibi two seconds later.

Who is named. Mr Johannes Madoda 'Joe Ferrari' Sibanyoni testified that Nkosi contacted him on General Mkhwanazi's behalf to arrange a meeting, and confirmed that Nkosi visited his home on about 12 occasions, which he described as social. He denied that Nkosi acted on his behalf in any official context, and said any message Nkosi sent referencing sensitive SAPS activities was a unilateral act, not at his request. Asked about involvement in a cabal, he said he had only heard about it. In an affidavit, Nkosi said he knew nothing about any corrupt relationship, and knew only that Matlala had close ties with Lieutenant General Sibiya and Major General Khan.

Conduct alleged to be unlawful. Mr Sesoko told the commission that what was presented involved corruption, manipulation of processes and issues of gratification. Adv Khumalo SC put to a witness the complaint that there is a cover-up by Crime Intelligence, and Adv Chaskalson SC raised the possibility that, had organised crime networks infiltrated SAPS, a suspect may have been tipped off about weapons linked to many scenes. Advocate Johnson said allegations implicating senior SAPS members sat in four dockets. Brigadier Nkhwashu, asked whether he had been told by somebody within SAPS, answered no.

The commission has not yet made findings. This overview summarises what was alleged in evidence; each number opens the claim it rests on.

People in this scheme
Johannes Madoda 'Joe Ferrari' Sibanyoni1
Timeline of events
●
11 March 2024
Nkosi sent a list of entities (likely companies or individuals) on 11 March 2024, potentially forwarding sensitive information.
action: He had sent them to me on the 11th of March
Day 93 · Mr Mnisi ·
●
18 March 2024
Nkosi placed phone calls to Deputy Chief Dhlamini, Mr Mthakathi Mswazi, General Sibiya, or Shibiri at 08:37 on 18 March 2024, part of his regular go-between communications.
called: you phone General Sibiya
Day 78 · Adv Chaskalson SC ·
called: 11:54 on the 17th of April 2024 you phoned Mr Mthakathi Mswazi
Day 80 · Adv Chaskalson SC ·
See all 6 claims →
◎
30 April 2024
Nkosi met with Mr Joe Sibanyoni (JS) at 4 o'clock on 30 April 2024, a meeting later discussed in testimony.
stated content: explaining that you were meeting Mr Sibanyoni at 4 o'clock
Day 82 · Adv Chaskalson SC ·
stated content: saying that you were still there at the foot of that screenshot
Day 82 · Adv Chaskalson SC ·
See all 19 claims →
●
26 June 2024
Nkosi forwarded three messages to the Chief Financial Officer at 13:49 on 26 June 2024, continuing his practice of sharing sensitive information.
stated action: Sergeant Nkosi says he is expecting it
Day 94 · Adv Chaskalson SC ·
●
September 2024
Sergeant Nkosi retrieved Mr Msibi's jet ski from Mr Matlala's farm approximately in September 2024, demonstrating his improper relationship with Matlala.
action taken: You told us earlier that you retrieved Mr Msibi's jet ski from Mr Matlala's farm approximately in September 2024.
Day 78 · Adv Chaskalson SC ·
order between these two not established
●
14 September 2024
Nkosi had a conversation with Mr Matlala at 07:25 on 14 September 2024, the only such communication that day before 19:00.
communication status with: the only conversation that Sergeant Nkosi had with Mr Matlala that day, before this 19:00 time, is at 07:25 in the morning
Day 65 · Adv Hassim SC ·
communication status with: There was not any other conversation between the two of them
Day 65 · Adv Hassim SC ·
●
27 November 2024
Nkosi collected equipment from Katiso Molefe on 27 November 2024, likely related to the illegal activities.
collected: you went round to collect the equipment on the 27th of November 2024
Day 83 · Advocate Chaskalson SC ·
●
4 December 2024
Nkosi contacted Mr Matlala on 4 December 2024, maintaining the corrupt information pipeline.
contacted: the day before, on the 5th and the 4th of December, you were in constant contact with Mr Matlala
Day 79 · Adv Khumalo SC ·
contacted: the day before, on the 5th and the 4th of December, you were in constant contact with Mr Matlala
Day 79 · Adv Khumalo SC ·
See all 3 claims →
●
2024-12-05 – 2024-12-06
Nkosi injured his foot and was treated at Netcare hospital on 5–6 December 2024, an incident that created a cover story or alibi.
injured: you had injured your foot
Day 79 · Adv Chaskalson SC ·
location: you were at a Netcare hospital getting treatment to your foot
Day 79 · Adv Chaskalson SC ·
●
16 December 2024
Nkosi received a phone call at 06:30 on 16 December 2024 instructing him to come and see "number 1" (likely a senior official).
told: he would have told you that there is an operation going on
Day 75 · Adv Baloyi SC ·
told: He tells you Cat is there already.
Day 76 · Adv Baloyi SC ·
See all 6 claims →
●
18 December 2024
Nkosi sent Mr Matlala's telephone number to someone on 18 December 2024, further facilitating illicit communication.
sent message content: Sergeant Nkosi sends you contact details on the 18 t h , you say?
Day 75 · Adv Baloyi SC ·
sent message content: he sent me even a name and a name of the shop where I was supposed to go for a drip for vitamin for the drip and where he sent me the telephone number you are saying of Mr Matlala on the 18 t h
Day 75 · Lieutenant General Shibiri ·
See all 3 claims →
●
9 February 2025
Nkosi shared a document with Mr Msibi, then returned a signed version and forwarded it to Mr Msibi at 22:24 on 9 February 2025, suggesting coordination on official documents with an external party.
shared with: Sergeant Nkosi shares that draft letter immediately with Mr Msibi
Day 161 · chats with Mr Msibi ·
returned signed document at: Sergeant Nkosi returns the signed document, we will look at the signed document in a minute, but 10:24:29 was when he returned it to Mr Jacob
Day 161 · chats with Mr Jacob ·
See all 3 claims →
●
5 March 2025
Sergeant Nkosi intervened to set in motion a process by which Mr Mnisi spoke to Chief Dlamini and conveyed messages on 5 March 2025.
action taken: Sergeant Nkosi intervened and set in stage a process by which Mr Mnisi spoke to Chief Dlamini
Day 181 · Adv Chaskalson SC ·
action taken: in a series of messages conveyed through Sergeant Nkosi on the 5t h of March all designed to get Gubis to be paid by Tshwane
Day 181 · Adv Chaskalson SC ·
●
25 March 2025
On 25 March 2025, Nkosi made a request (possibly for a phone number or document), continuing his role as go-between.
requested: He requested it on the 25th, SC
Day 97 · General Dlamini ·
●
9 October 2025
A raid took place on 9 October 2025, the day after Nkosi's action on 8 October, likely a police operation linked to the scheme.
action status: you have failed or refused, made a decision not to give us the reason
Day 79 · Adv Baloyi SC ·
action status: the very next day you were raided and the money was found and seized
Day 83 · Adv Chaskalson SC ·
See all 3 claims →
●
21 July 2026
On 21 July 2026, Nkosi submitted a complaint letter with a mandate, claimed no knowledge of corrupt ties, and met in a prison boardroom while possessing Matlala's bank card. A magistrate ended proceedings with a condition naming Padayachee as a go-between.
contains: Our office has been mandated by Mr Fannie Nkosi
Day 149 · Adv Sello SC ·
accompanied by: I was called out from my detention cell by the senior prison official known to me as Mr Matlala
Day 149 · affidavit of Sergeant Nkosi ·
See all 11 claims →