SC0009
Julius Mkhwanazi disciplinary process (EMPD)
IPID recommendation re Mkhwanazi disciplinary steps. Gxasheka (HR) vs Sello SC + Chairperson + Baloyi SC + IPID report dispute on whether discipline was recommended.
13 events4 contradictions
People in this scheme
Commissioner Julius Mkhwanazi (suspended EMPD/Metr16Ms Gxasheka (HOD HR)12Commissioner/Brigadier Mkhwanazi of EMPD11Zenzile Nxumalo4Mr Vusimuzi 'Cat' Matlala3Bonginkosi Mashazi2Jabulani Isaac Mapiyeye2Advocate Kemi Behari1
Timeline of events
●
2022
Julius Mkhwanazi facilitated the registration of vehicles owned by CAT VIP Security under the City of Ekurhuleni without proper authority, enabling private vehicles to operate as municipal fleet. He obtained ID documents and submitted them to Chris Steyn for registration.
memory of discussion: Yes, yes.
stated conclusion: a private entity was sitting with vehicles of the city, because they are registered as the city’s vehicles.
●
2022
Julius Mkhwanazi attended the scene of a murder in Brakpan, allegedly gave instructions for body disposal, and later made statements to IPID containing inconsistencies. His presence and instructions are disputed.
contacted by law enforcement members after death: several members of that operation who were in law enforcement telephoned you and sought your assistance in covering up the events
instructed body disposal: he looked at him and indicated that somebody needs to dump the body ... into either a dam or a mining shaft
R
5 May 2022
EMPD Commissioner Julius Mkhwanazi received multiple cash payments from businessman Vusi (Cat) Matlala — including amounts for personal expenses and funeral assistance — while Matlala was involved with the municipality. Payments acknowledged by Mkhwanazi.
received money for food from: For food.
gave money to: he will then say no 'ngamla' I will give you some, you see.
R
2022-07-29 – 2022-07-31
Mr Ze Nxumalo (businessman, owner of Zig Revenue Management) paid Onyx Aviation to fly Ekurhuleni City Manager Dr Mabotlanyo Imogen Mashazi, her husband Mr Bonginkosi Mashazi, Ms Seletswane, Mr Maleka, and others on a private charter to London over the weekend of 29–31 July 2022. The group stayed at the Corinthia Hotel. Counsel at the Commission asked explicitly what influence, protection, or access was expected from Mashazi in return in her capacity as City Manager — in the context of her decisions to uplift Julius Mkhwanazi's suspension and discipline (SC0009 E000120) and to place Chief Mapiyeye on leave after the precious stones complaint (SC0012 E000153).
subject matter: There is the issue of what we call the Mashazi trip
subject matter: a trip to London, a weekend trip to London, which also emerges from some of the conversations with General Khan
◆
2023
HOD HR Linda Gxasheka was aware that Commissioner Julius Mkhwanazi refused vetting for himself and his entire command. She directed him in writing that vetting must happen and said she was supporting it — but gave no further follow-up when he continued to resist, and later participated in withdrawing his disciplinary proceedings (E000120). Her passivity allowed the vetting refusal to stand.
feedback on vetting process: There was no further feedback from Gxasheka
action taken: I did not zoom down to see that indeed, it is only his department that does not want to be vetted
◎
20 February 2023
Xolani Nciza discussed with Linda Gxasheka the intention to suspend Brigadier Julius Mkhwanazi. Gxasheka expressed safety concerns but agreed to the pre-suspension letter, issued the same day.
is screenshot of: this is indeed screenshots of the communications that I had with Ms Gxasheka
confirmed: Yes, it does.
◆
24 February 2023
Brigadier Julius Mkhwanazi was suspended from EMPD pending investigation into misconduct — including blue light use, vehicle registration irregularities, and other allegations. Suspension letter dated 24 February 2023, effective immediately.
suspension date: On the 24th of February, Brigadier Mkhwanazi was placed on suspension with this case of the blue light saga.
title: The title of the document is Suspension Letter
◆
12 April 2023
Chief Mapiyeye approved a request for a disciplinary tribunal against Brigadier Julius Mkhwanazi on 12 April 2023. The tribunal was subsequently halted by intervention from the City Manager and HOD HR before it could convene.
disciplinary tribunal request date: On 23rd March 2023, I requested that disciplinary tribunal be established.
disciplinary tribunal approval date: This was approved on the 12th of April 2023.
◆
2023-06-20 – 2023-06-21
Following instructions from the City Manager and HOD HR, Julius Mkhwanazi's suspension was uplifted (20–21 June 2023) and internal disciplinary proceedings withdrawn (letter dated 22 June 2023), despite pending IPID recommendations and the April tribunal approval.
action taken: HR uplifted Brigadier Mkhwanazi’s suspension with immediate effect and directed him to resume duty
stated characterisation: The effect of this letter was not to withdraw the disciplinary processes.
◆
September 2023
IPID delivered a report to the City of Ekurhuleni with findings of fraud and corruption, directing that disciplinary proceedings be instituted against Julius Mkhwanazi. Received by both the Chief of Police and the City Manager.
instruction to mapiyeye: They wrote to him as the Chief of Police to discipline Julius.
content characterisation: post the Commission and the evidence that we received, the report is full of gross misconduct
◆
3 October 2023
IPID issued a separate negative recommendation on 3 October 2023 regarding the blue lights scandal, directing the City to institute disciplinary proceedings. IPID stated there was overwhelming evidence against Julius Mkhwanazi.
paragraph 2 content: In terms of section 30 of the IPID Act, read with a SALGA disciplinary procedure, you are hereby directed … Yes, is that what you are looking for? You are hereby directed to initiate.
heading at page 103: under the heading IPID recommendation
★
1 December 2023
Despite two adverse IPID reports and pending disciplinary processes, Julius Mkhwanazi was promoted to Deputy Chief of Police Operations at EMPD, effective 1 December 2023.
appointment date: Julius was appointed on the 1st of December 2023
content: On 1 December 2023 Brigadier Mkhwanazi was purportedly appointed as the Deputy Chief of Police Operations and Specialised Services.
★
2024-05-06 – 2024-05-17
Julius Mkhwanazi was appointed Acting Chief of Police for EMPD from 6 to 17 May 2024 by the City Manager — while still facing potential disciplinary action following two adverse IPID reports.
acting appointment period: he was appointed from the 6th to the 17th of May to act in the position of Chief of Police
appointer of: the appointment was made by myself
Contradictions linked to this scheme
◎ Likely — AI-assisted, cited
Commissioner/Brigadier Mkhwanazi of EMPD — (cross-phrasing)
One says not suspended, the other says suspended in Feb 2023 — same person, cannot both hold.
◎ Likely — AI-assisted, cited
Commissioner/Brigadier Mkhwanazi of EMPD — (cross-phrasing)
Same suspension event dated 2023-02-24 vs 2025-02-24; both cannot be true for same person/event.
◎ Likely — AI-assisted, cited
Adv Harrison's letter to Lt-Gen Mkhwanazi — date
Value 1
2023-06-21Value 2
2023-06-22◎ Likely — AI-assisted, cited
Commissioner/Brigadier Mkhwanazi of EMPD — (cross-phrasing)
One says promoted to Deputy Chief, other says became Chief of Police; different ranks for same person cannot both hold.