WhatTheySaid.co.zaThe Madlanga Commission record, in plain language
SC0009

Julius Mkhwanazi disciplinary process (EMPD)

The allegation. According to evidence before the commission, a serious misconduct case against a senior metro police officer was opened and then stopped before it could be heard. Commissioner Julius Mkhwanazi was placed on suspension on 24 February 2023 over what a witness called the "blue light saga". Within months the suspension was lifted, the internal process was halted, and in December he was promoted rather than dismissed. Counsel put it to a witness that attempts to discipline him had been frustrated.

How it allegedly worked. Chief Isaac Jabulani Mapiyeye testified that on 3 March 2023 he determined the misconduct complaint was of a serious nature, that he then asked for a disciplinary tribunal, and that this was approved on 12 April 2023. Mr Nciza testified that a hearing had been envisaged for 3 July. It never took place. Commissioner Revo Spies testified that the suspension was uplifted by Ms Gxasheka; Mapiyeye said HR lifted it with immediate effect and directed Mkhwanazi to resume duty. Counsel put to Mapiyeye that he had been instructed to withdraw the charges and had written to Mkhwanazi telling him of a decision to withdraw the internal investigation processes. Mapiyeye testified that the effect of his letter was not to withdraw the disciplinary processes. Advocate Kemi Behari told the commission that in about September 2023 the Independent Police Investigative Directorate delivered a report to the City containing disciplinary recommendations and referring to potential criminal conduct, and Mr Keefelakae said recommendations submitted on 3 October 2023 were that disciplinary action be taken against Mkhwanazi.

Who is named. Mkhwanazi was appointed Deputy Chief of Police on 1 December 2023, and Dr Imogen Mashazi testified that she appointed him to act as Chief of Police from 6 to 17 May 2024. Ms Linda Gxasheka testified that she supported and directed that vetting must happen and wrote to Mkhwanazi about it, but did not check whether his was the only department resisting; Spies testified there was no further feedback from her. Lieutenant General Godfrey Lebeya testified that on 22 July 2024 he told IPID the report was being studied, and that he advised the SAPS that the DPCI would institute its own disciplinary process.

Conduct alleged to be unlawful. The underlying allegations concern payments and police favours. Counsel took Mkhwanazi to a payment of R20,000 from Cat Protection and Security Services and R20,000 from Medicare24 Tshwane District; he testified that Mr Vusimuzi "Cat" Matlala used to assist him and had helped with money for a funeral. Advocate Sesi Baloyi SC put to him that a private entity held vehicles registered as the city's; Mkhwanazi said he would not commit himself to "facilitation". On a Brakpan death scene, counsel put to him that he said a body must be dumped; he testified that he moved towards the gate and drove away.

The commission has not yet made findings. This overview summarises what was alleged in evidence; each number opens the claim it rests on.

People in this scheme
Commissioner Julius Mkhwanazi (suspended EMPD/Metr27Ms Gxasheka (HOD HR)12Lieutenant General Godfrey Lebeya8Zenzile Nxumalo4Advocate Sesi Baloyi, SC3Mr Vusimuzi 'Cat' Matlala3Bonginkosi Mashazi2Jabulani Isaac Mapiyeye2
Timeline of events
●
2022
Julius Mkhwanazi facilitated the registration of vehicles owned by CAT VIP Security under the City of Ekurhuleni without proper authority, enabling private vehicles to operate as municipal fleet. He obtained ID documents and submitted them to Chris Steyn for registration.
memory of discussion: Yes, yes.
Day 43 · Commissioner Mkhwanazi ·
stated conclusion: a private entity was sitting with vehicles of the city, because they are registered as the city’s vehicles.
Day 43 · Adv Baloyi SC ·
See all 7 claims →
order between these two not established
●
2022
Julius Mkhwanazi attended the scene of a murder in Brakpan, allegedly gave instructions for body disposal, and later made statements to IPID containing inconsistencies. His presence and instructions are disputed.
contacted by law enforcement members after death: several members of that operation who were in law enforcement telephoned you and sought your assistance in covering up the events
Day 44 · Adv Motlhasedi ·
instructed body disposal: he looked at him and indicated that somebody needs to dump the body ... into either a dam or a mining shaft
Day 44 · Adv Motlhasedi ·
See all 7 claims →
order between these two not established
R
5 May 2022
EMPD Commissioner Julius Mkhwanazi received multiple cash payments from businessman Vusi (Cat) Matlala — including amounts for personal expenses and funeral assistance — while Matlala was involved with the municipality. Payments acknowledged by Mkhwanazi.
received money for food from: For food.
Day 44 · Chairperson ·
gave money to: he will then say no 'ngamla' I will give you some, you see.
Day 44 · Commissioner Mkhwanazi ·
See all 7 claims →
R
2022-07-29 – 2022-07-31
Mr Ze Nxumalo (businessman, owner of Zig Revenue Management) paid Onyx Aviation to fly Ekurhuleni City Manager Dr Mabotlanyo Imogen Mashazi, her husband Mr Bonginkosi Mashazi, Ms Seletswane, Mr Maleka, and others on a private charter to London over the weekend of 29–31 July 2022. The group stayed at the Corinthia Hotel. Counsel at the Commission asked explicitly what influence, protection, or access was expected from Mashazi in return in her capacity as City Manager — in the context of her decisions to uplift Julius Mkhwanazi's suspension and discipline (SC0009 E000120) and to place Chief Mapiyeye on leave after the precious stones complaint (SC0012 E000153).
subject matter: There is the issue of what we call the Mashazi trip
Day 132 · Adv Hassim SC ·
subject matter: a trip to London, a weekend trip to London, which also emerges from some of the conversations with General Khan
Day 132 · Adv Hassim SC ·
See all 28 claims →
◆
2023
HOD HR Linda Gxasheka was aware that Commissioner Julius Mkhwanazi refused vetting for himself and his entire command. She directed him in writing that vetting must happen and said she was supporting it — but gave no further follow-up when he continued to resist, and later participated in withdrawing his disciplinary proceedings (E000120). Her passivity allowed the vetting refusal to stand.
feedback on vetting process: There was no further feedback from Gxasheka
Day 30 · Commissioner Revo Spies ·
action taken: I did not zoom down to see that indeed, it is only his department that does not want to be vetted
Day 69 · Ms Linda Gxasheka ·
See all 11 claims →
order between these two not established
◎
20 February 2023
Xolani Nciza discussed with Linda Gxasheka the intention to suspend Brigadier Julius Mkhwanazi. Gxasheka expressed safety concerns but agreed to the pre-suspension letter, issued the same day.
is screenshot of: this is indeed screenshots of the communications that I had with Ms Gxasheka
Day 30 · Mr Nciza ·
confirmed: Yes, it does.
Day 31 · Mr Nciza ·
See all 4 claims →
◆
24 February 2023
Brigadier Julius Mkhwanazi was suspended from EMPD pending investigation into misconduct — including blue light use, vehicle registration irregularities, and other allegations. Suspension letter dated 24 February 2023, effective immediately.
suspension date: On the 24th of February, Brigadier Mkhwanazi was placed on suspension with this case of the blue light saga.
Day 28 · Isaac Jabulani Mapiyeye ·
title: The title of the document is Suspension Letter
Day 31 · Mr Nciza ·
See all 6 claims →
◆
12 April 2023
Chief Mapiyeye approved a request for a disciplinary tribunal against Brigadier Julius Mkhwanazi on 12 April 2023. The tribunal was subsequently halted by intervention from the City Manager and HOD HR before it could convene.
disciplinary tribunal request date: On 23rd March 2023, I requested that disciplinary tribunal be established.
Day 28 · Isaac Jabulani Mapiyeye ·
disciplinary tribunal approval date: This was approved on the 12th of April 2023.
Day 28 · Isaac Jabulani Mapiyeye ·
See all 5 claims →
◆
2023-06-20 – 2023-06-21
Following instructions from the City Manager and HOD HR, Julius Mkhwanazi's suspension was uplifted (20–21 June 2023) and internal disciplinary proceedings withdrawn (letter dated 22 June 2023), despite pending IPID recommendations and the April tribunal approval.
action taken: HR uplifted Brigadier Mkhwanazi’s suspension with immediate effect and directed him to resume duty
Day 28 · Chief Mapiyeye ·
stated characterisation: The effect of this letter was not to withdraw the disciplinary processes.
Day 28 · Chief Mapiyeye ·
See all 12 claims →
◆
September 2023
IPID delivered a report to the City of Ekurhuleni with findings of fraud and corruption, directing that disciplinary proceedings be instituted against Julius Mkhwanazi. Received by both the Chief of Police and the City Manager.
instruction to mapiyeye: They wrote to him as the Chief of Police to discipline Julius.
Day 41 · Dr Mashazi ·
content characterisation: post the Commission and the evidence that we received, the report is full of gross misconduct
Day 41 · Dr Mashazi ·
See all 40 claims →
◆
3 October 2023
IPID issued a separate negative recommendation on 3 October 2023 regarding the blue lights scandal, directing the City to institute disciplinary proceedings. IPID stated there was overwhelming evidence against Julius Mkhwanazi.
paragraph 2 content: In terms of section 30 of the IPID Act, read with a SALGA disciplinary procedure, you are hereby directed … Yes, is that what you are looking for? You are hereby directed to initiate.
Day 56 · Adv Baloyi SC ·
heading at page 103: under the heading IPID recommendation
Day 56 · Adv Baloyi SC ·
See all 4 claims →
★
1 December 2023
Despite two adverse IPID reports and pending disciplinary processes, Julius Mkhwanazi was promoted to Deputy Chief of Police Operations at EMPD, effective 1 December 2023.
appointment date: Julius was appointed on the 1st of December 2023
Day 27 · Chief Mapiyeye ·
content: On 1 December 2023 Brigadier Mkhwanazi was purportedly appointed as the Deputy Chief of Police Operations and Specialised Services.
Day 28 · Adv Sello SC ·
See all 5 claims →
★
2024-05-06 – 2024-05-17
Julius Mkhwanazi was appointed Acting Chief of Police for EMPD from 6 to 17 May 2024 by the City Manager — while still facing potential disciplinary action following two adverse IPID reports.
acting appointment period: he was appointed from the 6th to the 17th of May to act in the position of Chief of Police
Day 42 · Doctor Mashazi ·
appointer of: the appointment was made by myself
Day 42 · Doctor Mashazi ·
See all 4 claims →
9 contradictions linked to this scheme
● Certain — deterministic◆ Cross-witness⟂ Independent source
ABS-8131782914e8
suspension date
2023 vs December 2025 are conflicting suspension years; February is incompatible with December. Genuine conflict on same single suspension date.
FD: suspension_date single-valued (allow-list) + value-typed
Day 28Isaac Jabulani Mapiyeye“On the 24th of February, Brigadier Mkhwanazi was placed on suspension with this case of the blue light saga.”
Day 44Commissioner Mkhwanazi“I was suspended 2023”
Day 56Adv Behari (Kemi)“Mr Mkhwanazi was suspended sometimes in February”
Day 57Adv Khumalo SC“He was suspended in December 2025”
◎ Likely — AI-assisted, cited◆ Cross-witness
NLI-a7ea84066f9b
One says not suspended, the other says suspended in Feb 2023 — same person, cannot both hold.
Day 31Mr Nciza“The person is not suspended, you know”
Day 31Adv Motlhasedi“Brigadier Mkhwanazi was suspended in February of 2023”
◎ Likely — AI-assisted, cited◆ Cross-witness
KNN-b37c152bf9b5
Same suspension event dated to different years: 2023-02-24 vs 2025-02-24; both cannot be the suspension date.
Day 28Isaac Jabulani Mapiyeye“On the 24th of February, Brigadier Mkhwanazi was placed on suspension with this case of the blue light saga.”
Day 29Commissioner Revo Spies“starting from February 24th, 2025”
◎ Likely — AI-assisted, cited◆ Cross-witness
KNN-1fdfc1248851
Same entity's suspension dated to Feb 2023 vs Dec 2025; cannot both be the suspension date.
Day 28Isaac Jabulani Mapiyeye“On the 24th of February, Brigadier Mkhwanazi was placed on suspension with this case of the blue light saga.”
Day 57Adv Khumalo SC“He was suspended in December 2025”
◎ Likely — AI-assisted, cited◆ Cross-witness
KNN-3d4690059306
Same suspension event dated to 2023-02 versus 2025-02-24; both cannot be true of the same suspension start.
Day 31Mr Nciza“Yes.”
Day 29Commissioner Revo Spies“starting from February 24th, 2025”
◎ Likely — AI-assisted, cited◆ Cross-witness
KNN-74e9b8821b83
Same entity's suspension date given as May 2025 vs February 2023; cannot both be true.
Day 29Commissioner Revo Spies“to May 24th, 2025”
Day 31Adv Motlhasedi“Brigadier Mkhwanazi was suspended in February of 2023”
◎ Likely — AI-assisted, cited◆ Cross-witness
KNN-7b4cf26435a1
Claim A dates suspension to 24 Feb over blue light saga; Claim B says December after Commission testimony—incompatible dates/triggers for same person.
Day 28Isaac Jabulani Mapiyeye“On the 24th of February, Brigadier Mkhwanazi was placed on suspension with this case of the blue light saga.”
Day 57Adv Khumalo SC“He was suspended in December after testimony in this Commission”
◎ Likely — AI-assisted, cited◆ Cross-witness
KNN-195f3df1875c
Suspension dated to two different times (2023-02 vs 2025-05-24) for same entity; cannot both be the suspension date.
Day 31Mr Nciza“Yes.”
Day 29Commissioner Revo Spies“to May 24th, 2025”
◎ Likely — AI-assisted, cited
KNN-f0e0be00d02b
Adv Harrison's letter to Lt-Gen Mkhwanazi
Same letter cannot bear two different dates: 2021-02-15 vs 2023-06-22.
“Dale: 2021 ·02· 1 S”
Day 28Adv Sello SC“it is dated the 22nd of June 2023”