WhatTheySaid.co.zaThe Madlanga Commission record, in plain language
SC0008

Illicit Mining Task Team funding

The allegation. Adv Sello SC put to the commission that the Illicit Mining Task Team is the most expensive of the units drawing on CARA funding, costing the state R1.1 billion over a three-year period from 2023/2024 to 2025/2026, measured up to 30 September 2025. He asked whether the country had "bigger problems than we accept" if task teams costing that much went unchallenged. Lieutenant General Sibiya testified that the task team is funded from the CARA fund. He also told the commission that illicit mining is a continuous phenomenon far bigger than the issue of the task team itself.

How it allegedly worked. The task team sits among a cluster of specialised units. Commissioner Mkhwanazi testified that it formed part of a group that also included the drug unit, the taxi task team and the truck hijacking task team, and that it addresses illicit mining in the City of Ekurhuleni. He said those involved contribute to crime and to land invasion. Sibiya testified that the team's work is not confined to one province but extends across provinces with an illicit mining problem. Counsel put to the commission that funding swung sharply from year to year: R738 million in one financial year and R294 million budgeted in the current year, and that the team was already in existence when the Marais report was issued.

Who is named. The spending figures were put by Adv Sello SC to Minister Senzo Mchunu, who said he saw the relevant entry for the task teams in the document before him. Sibiya spoke to the funding and the reach of the unit, and Mkhwanazi to its work in Ekurhuleni. Major-General Richard Shibiri testified that Economic Infrastructure and Illicit Mining deals with mining of this kind. On the ground, Mr Brown Mogotsi gave evidence about a Zama-Zama kingpin who ran away from custody, and Superintendent De Beer gave evidence touching on Zama-Zamas and on former Superintendent Manyama.

Conduct alleged to be unlawful. The complaint before the commission is that heavy spending has run alongside police themselves shielding mining suspects. Sibiya testified that one of the main kingpins was arrested and the police let him go, saying he had also heard the man was allegedly led by police to run away, and that those arrested are able to pay their way out, as are the people working with them. Mogotsi's account differed in emphasis: he testified that the man, from Stilfontein, was arrested in December 2024 and ran away, but said he could not confirm where this happened and that his information came from the community. A statement by Superintendent De Beer, read into evidence, alleged that Manyama protected individuals implicated in the killing of a Zama-Zama miner.

The commission has not yet made findings. This overview summarises what was alleged in evidence; each number opens the claim it rests on.

People in this scheme
Zama Zama kingpin who ran away from custody13former Superintendent Manyama1
Timeline of events
◎
19 January 2024
A meeting was held on 19 January 2024 to discuss concerns about Zama Zama activity and the seizure of firearms from EMPD officers — showing the intersection of illicit mining enforcement and the EMPD misconduct thread.
subject matter: concerns regarding Zama Zama's and seizure of firearms of EMPD officers
Day 60 · Adv Sello SC ·
subject matter: Yes, I confirm that.
Day 60 · Mr Magagula ·
See all 3 claims →
⚡
December 2024
An illegal mining kingpin — reportedly a Lesotho national operating in Stilfontein — was arrested but allegedly allowed to escape by police officers. Multiple testimonies refer to the same individual across December 2024 and January 2025.
arrest status: That person was arrested, and he ran away
Day 37 · Brown Mogotsi ·
origin location: From Stilfontein
Day 37 · Brown Mogotsi ·
See all 14 claims →
order between these two not established
●
6 December 2024
A minister's statement referenced a police operation on 6 December 2024 in the context of illicit mining allegations and associations.
content: Under that heading, it is allegations, alleged association with Mr Vusimusi Cat Matlala, knowledge of the 6 December 2024 operation, knowledge or involvement in December 24 arrest of Mr Katiso Molefe,
Day 45 · Adv Sello SC ·
Position on the timeline not established by the record
◆
undated
Testimony presented two budget figures for the Illicit Mining Task Team — R294 million for one fiscal year and R738 million for the next, a 150% increase. The same figures were attributed to the same entity under examination, constituting the core funding discrepancy of this scheme. Exact fiscal years and the decision date are not specified in the corpus.
stated cost: the most expensive is the illicit mining, only CARA funding, at 1.1 billion over a three-year period, 2023/2024 up to 2025/2026, and that is up to the 30th of September 2025.
Day 45 · Adv Sello SC ·
total cost zar: the Illicit Mining Task Team, the most expensive that has cost the nation thus far 1.1 billion.
Day 45 · Adv Sello SC ·
See all 8 claims →
●
undated
Former superintendent Manyama allegedly protected individuals implicated in the killing of an illegal miner, a Zama-Zama. This suggests possible official protection in illegal mining violence relevant to the task team scheme.
alleged conduct: protecting individuals implicated in the killing of an illegal miner, a Zama-Zama
Day 173 · Superintendent De Beer's statement ·
1 contradiction linked to this scheme
◎ Likely — AI-assisted, cited◆ Cross-witness
KNN-f043f5842943
Same kingpin's release: one says he ran away from custody, other says police let him go—incompatible accounts.
Day 37Brown Mogotsi“That person was arrested, and he ran away”
Day 71Lieutenant General Sibiya“one of the main kingpins was arrested and the police let him go”