EMPD drug enforcement + criminal-records vetting
The allegation. Evidence before the commission describes failures in screening the records of employees in two police bodies. A once-off check of Ekurhuleni Metropolitan Police Department employees found 3,174 clear, 275 flagged for illicit activity and 100 with convictions, Commissioner Revo Spies testified, for offences including murder, rape and fraud. Mr Keefelakae testified that drugs, and trucks carrying consignments of goods, were the "terrain" of one EMPD silo, and that "the EMPD is involved in those kinds of things". In SAPS Crime Intelligence, Advocate Andrea Johnson testified about the bypassing of vetting processes, and about allegations that a high-ranking officer manipulated promotion and security vetting to benefit a civilian.
How it allegedly worked. Municipal police have no access to SAPS criminal record systems, Spies testified, and fingerprints were historically taken only on recruitment and at promotion; a chiefs' forum then agreed that all members' fingerprints be submitted manually to SAPS for a once-off verification. Counsel put it that a directive dated 21 December 2021 from IJ Mapiyeye, Commissioner Chief of Police, went to all divisional heads and employees. Counsel also put it that annual verification of every employee's record is a standing requirement, and that the whole Specialised Services unit had refused vetting. Documents put to witnesses record a memorandum of agreement dated 16 October 2021, signed by Brigadier JD Mkhwanazi, with CAT VIP Protection under Mr Vusimuzi Matlala, and an agreement with Medicare 24/Anubis Protection Services under which the EMPD would register that firm's vehicles as "official vehicles" permitted to use blue and red lights. A letter recorded that eight CAT VIP members were requested to assist the EMPD's VIP team at a State of the City Address.
Who is named. Commissioner Julius Mkhwanazi, the suspended EMPD chief, is central. Chief Isaac Jabulani Mapiyeye testified that Mkhwanazi refused vetting, sending a WhatsApp saying it was not in line with his conditions of appointment; Spies said he "blatantly refused" and asserted he was exempt. Mapiyeye testified that he was suspended over the blue-light matter, though witnesses gave differing dates. Mr Nciza testified that an IPID report contained damning findings against him. Colonel Brian Padayachee testified that Brigadier Dineo Mokwele, a civilian, could not apply through the e-Vetting system yet her vetting was captured on it, and that Brigadier Ncube instead proceeded as though appointing a service provider. Johnson testified that the vetting of Lt Gen Samuel Dumisani Khumalo and Major-General Nosipho Precious Madondo had been questioned.
Conduct alleged to be unlawful. Mr Magagula testified that EMPD officers abused their powers by operating outside their jurisdiction, citing a complainant stopped by members in an unmarked BMW in Boksburg on 5 March 2024. Padayachee said the manipulation of the vetting process prejudiced the SAPS and gave Mokwele an undue advantage; counsel put the contrary view, that vetting before her interview in fact disadvantaged her. Spies said the EMPD was "not even listed" in one operation's records, while the chairperson put to another witness that the EMPD was part of that operation.
The commission has not yet made findings. This overview summarises what was alleged in evidence; each number opens the claim it rests on.