WhatTheySaid.co.zaThe Madlanga Commission record, in plain language
SC0004

TMPD / Tshwane Metro Police tenders

The allegation. Security services for the City of Tshwane are bought through tenders worth very large sums, and witnesses described a procurement system that kept breaking down. Adv Khumalo SC put to a witness his concern about "dishing out tenders where you are spending billions of rands", referring to a figure of R2.9 billion. Mr Gareth Mnisi, whom counsel questioned about his appointment as chief financial officer of Tshwane, testified that the Tshwane Municipal Police Department owns this tender, carries the designated responsibility for it, and makes funding available so it is executed. Witnesses described a cycle in which tenders ran late or failed and existing providers stayed on through extension requests, because the service was still needed.

How it allegedly worked. Commissioner Faro, the Chief of Police, testified that the TMPD plays a role in the bid specifications. The chairperson put to him that the TMPD is not involved in bid evaluation or bid adjudication. Commissioner Spies testified that the oldest contract, tender TMPD 2/2016/2017, for physical security to protect the property, assets and personnel of the municipality, was approved by the then Chief of Police, Mr KS Ngobeni, on 19 July 2016; After a court ruling it commenced only on 1 March 2022, with 22 companies awarded, Spies said. The replacement tenders also failed. Mnisi testified that TMPD1 was cancelled and the defect "not curable". Adv Chaskalson SC put that TMPD3 was advertised on 12 August 2024 and cancelled on 23 October. Accounts of the evaluation committee's work differ: counsel put that it recommended an award in late May 2025, while Mnisi testified that it brought a report with resolutions already in it that a tender must be cancelled.

Who is named. Faro testified that, according to the award appointment letters, the tender was managed by Director Tshukudu Malatji and Mr Nava Pillay within the Asset Protection Unit. Commissioner Bolhuis testified that the asset protection function was moved to the Office of the City Manager, reporting to Pillay, from 13 March 2021, and transferred back to the TMPD from 1 July 2024. A document read into evidence recorded that Gubis 85 Security Solutions was appointed to provide VIP protection and escort services. Chaskalson put that in March 2025 Gubis asked why it had not been paid, that Sergeant Fannie Nkosi intervened, and that Mnisi then spoke to Chief Dlamini, the Deputy Head of Security in the TMPD.

Conduct alleged to be unlawful. The evidence points to irregularity in how these tenders were specified, scored and abandoned rather than to one named offence. Adv Sikhakhane put that an outcome would have cost the City, and the TMPD in particular, R96 million. Bolhuis testified that if he had a way to force the matter through he would, as he was also the chief of staff. Mnisi testified that other TMPD contracts are smaller in nature, and that some problems cannot be cured.

The commission has not yet made findings. This overview summarises what was alleged in evidence; each number opens the claim it rests on.

People in this scheme
Mr Mnisi5DJ Sumbody1
Timeline of events
◆
19 July 2016
The tender TMPD02/2016/2017 for physical guarding services was approved by the then Chief of Police, Mr KS Ngobeni.
approval status: on 19 July 2016 this was approved by the then Chief of Police, Mr KS Ngobeni
Day 84 · Commissioner Spies ·
●
September 2016
The Supply Chain Management Department advertised tender TMPD02/2016/2017 for physical guarding services in September 2016.
action taken: The Supply Chain Management subsequently advertised their tender, TMPD2, 2016 - 2017, in September 2016 together with other tenders
Day 87 · Director Malatji ·
contains: to render specialised VIP protection, escort and defence security services
Day 169 · Adv Chaskalson SC ·
See all 3 claims →
◆
13 March 2021
A letter directed that Asset Protection Function and Personnel based at the Tshwane Metro Police Department be moved to the Office of the City Manager to report under Mr Pillay, effective 13 March 2021.
content: the current Asset Protection Function and Personnel that have been identified who are based at the Tshwane Metro Police Department temporarily are moved to the Office of the City Manager to report und
Day 86 · Commissioner Bolhuis ·
★
2022
Mr Gareth Mnisi was appointed as Chief Financial Officer of the City of Tshwane Metropolitan Municipality — a position that made him chair of the Bid Adjudication Committee.
appointment date: when did Mr Mnisi come to Tshwane? When did he become the CFO?
Day 81 · Adv Chaskalson SC ·
order between these two not established
◆
1 March 2022
By agreement between the parties, a court ordered that the decision to cancel tender TMPD02/2016/17 be set aside, reinstating the process.
occurred on: the tender then officially commenced on 1 March 2022 with this list of 22 companies that was awarded in the ruling by the court
Day 84 · Commissioner Spies ·
occurred on: the tender then commenced 1 March 2022
Day 84 · Commissioner Spies ·
See all 3 claims →
●
November 2023
Mr Gareth Mnisi was suspended from his position as CFO at the City of Tshwane. He was later reinstated.
employment status: Since November 2023
Day 94 · Mr Mnisi ·
employment status: it is about 16, 17 months already
Day 94 · Advocate Chaskalson SC ·
●
1 July 2024
The Asset Protection Security Services unit was relocated from the Office of the City Manager back to the Tshwane Metro Police Department, effective 1 July 2024 — reversing the 2021 move.
location: when the Asset Protection Unit was relocated from the City Manager's Office to the Metro Police Department on 1 July 2024
Day 84 · Commissioner Spies ·
composition includes: remember 1st of July 2024 …[intervenes]
Day 85 · Commissioner Faro (Chief of Police) ·
See all 4 claims →
●
12 August 2024
Tender TMPD03/2024/2025 for security services was advertised on 12 August 2024.
advertised date: the bid was advertised on the 12th of August 2024
Day 98 · Adv Chaskalson SC ·
●
December 2024
VIP protection officers assigned to CFO Mnisi (officers Nkomo and Mabunda of TMPD) were reassigned and his security was withdrawn.
occurred on: About December.
Day 92 · Mr Mnisi ·
security removed: Roughly in December 2024, yes.
Day 94 · Mr Mnisi ·
See all 5 claims →
order between these two not established
↓
December 2024
A raid occurred at CAT VIP Services where firearms were taken and a key was found not in the correct safe, connected to the VIP protection business linked to the TMPD tender scheme.
occurred: there was a raid at CAT VIP Services
Day 165 · Adv Khumalo SC ·
issue: there was the issue with the key and the fact that it is not in the right safe
Day 165 · Adv Khumalo SC ·
See all 3 claims →
order between these two not established
●
12 December 2024
Tender TMPD01/2024/2025 for monitoring and prevention of illegal land and building occupation was advertised on 12 December 2024.
advertisement date: The bid was advertised on the 12t h of December 2024 with a closing date of 21 February
Day 94 · Advocate Chaskalson SC ·
advertisement date: 12t h of December, 21s t of February, yes
Day 94 · Mr Mnisi ·
●
21 February 2025
The closing date for tender TMPD01/2024/2025 was 21 February 2025.
closing date: closing date of 21 February
Day 94 · Advocate Chaskalson SC ·
closing date: 12t h of December, 21s t of February, yes
Day 94 · Mr Mnisi ·
R
March 2025
In March 2025, Gubis called Sergeant Nkosi and CFO Gareth Mnisi to ask why it had not been paid. Sergeant Nkosi intervened and arranged for Mr Mnisi to speak with TMPD Deputy Head of Security Chief Dlamini.
action taken: ostensibly were called by Gubis to say, why have we not been paid?
Day 181 · Adv Chaskalson SC ·
action taken: Sergeant Nkosi intervened and set in stage a process by which Mr Mnisi spoke to Chief Dlamini
Day 181 · Adv Chaskalson SC ·
See all 3 claims →
order between these two not established
◎
24 March 2025
A Bid Evaluation Committee meeting attended by Mr Mnisi, Sergeant Nkosi, and Deputy Chief Dhlamini to discuss TMPD-related matters.
occurred on: let us meet General tomorrow, which would be the 24th of March
Day 93 · Advocate Chaskalson SC ·
occurred on: The first meeting of the BEC was 24 March 2025
Day 98 · Adv Chaskalson SC ·
◎
11 April 2025
The Bid Evaluation Committee scored the bids submitted for the TMPD01 tender on 11 April 2025, as part of a series of BEC meetings from March to April 2025.
action: the 11th of April was the date of the original BEC scoring, that at that meeting, they actually scored the bids
Day 92 · Advocate Chaskalson SC ·
◆
2025-05-28 – 2025-05-29
The Bid Adjudication Committee recommended the appointment of 22 entities for security services under the TMPD02 tender extension.
recommendation: you would have recommended that these 22 entities be appointed for providing security services
Day 87 · Adv Sikhakhane ·
recommendation: all the bidders including Triotic, I think, they were recommended
Day 87 · Director Malatji ·
See all 3 claims →
◎
2025-09-04 – 2025-09-25
The Bid Adjudication Committee met on 4, 18, and 25 September 2025 regarding the TMPD01 tender, ultimately referring the evaluation report back to BEC for revision due to irregularities.
occurred on: It was on the 4th of September 2025
Day 92 · Mr Mnisi ·
occurred on: It was on the 18th of September 2025
Day 92 · Mr Mnisi ·
See all 7 claims →
order between these two not established
◆
25 September 2025
Tender TMPD01/2024/2025 was cancelled by the BAC following multiple referrals back to BEC and persistent irregularities that could not be resolved.
status: this tender was cancelled
Day 92 · Mr Mnisi ·
status: There are instances where matters cannot be cured.
Day 94 · Mr Mnisi ·
See all 3 claims →
◆
23 October 2025
The Bid Adjudication Committee cancelled tender TMPD03/2024/2025 on 23 October 2025 due to material irregularities including missing documents.
subject matter: in relation to TMPD-3
Day 94 · Advocate Chaskalson SC ·
decision: The BAC resolved to cancel the tender on 23 October.
Day 98 · Adv Chaskalson SC ·
1 contradiction linked to this scheme
◎ Likely — AI-assisted, cited◆ Cross-witness
NLI-4e66a5900c17
Bid Evaluation Committee
BEC cannot both recommend cancelling the tender and recommend awarding it; these are mutually exclusive outcomes for the same tender.
Day 94Mr Mnisi“The BEC brought a report with these resolutions already there that the tender must be cancelled.”
Day 98Adv Chaskalson SC“The BEC recommended an award on either 28 May or 29 May.”