Who paid the lawyer? A taxi association, a December meeting and a R250,000 compromise
On 29 September, taxi industry leader Joe Sibanyoni was asked a short question about a long-running set of legal bills. The bills were for the defence of a man the Commission called Gwabo Mahlangu. A message forwarded by Mr Sibanyoni to Mr Bafana Sindane recorded the verdict: “Charge 1, murder, guilty”.
“So were you paying Gwabo’s legal fees?” the evidence leader, Advocate Chaskalson SC, asked. “No,” Mr Sibanyoni said. Asked who was, he answered: “The association where his dad was operating.”
His role, as he described it, was to ask. Gwabo’s family had reached out to him — “his mother reached out to me” — because of his relationship with Gwabo’s late father. He took the matter to the taxi association, telling them that helping Gwabo was “not a direct assistance, it is an assistance in honour of the late Mr Mahlangu”. “And they did assist to a certain extent.” Later he put it more plainly: “we have been assisting Gwabo about the legal fees via the same taxi association.” When an advocate put to him that the assistance was nonetheless for Gwabo’s legal fees, he agreed: “I know that.”
The Commission then turned to the attorney’s side of the story, as recorded in his own messages. In May 2025 Mr Ngoato wrote to Mr Sibanyoni that, “due to non-payment”, he could not proceed with Gwabo’s matter, and that at a meeting in December “it was agreed that the money paid for Morwa must be used to cover for Gwabo”. Morwa is the name the Commission used for Tshegofatso Richmond Makofane, another man Mr Ngoato represented, and whom Mr Sibanyoni described as having been his driver at one point.
Mr Sibanyoni confirmed that he met Mr Ngoato in December 2024, but said the arrangement about Morwa’s money was not his doing. “It was not my instruction,” he said. He described how he runs such meetings: “I just coordinate the meeting”, ask that the fees be paid, and leave the rest to the parties — “so as to the nitty-gritties of their negotiations, I am not involved.” When payments stopped, he said, he called Mr Ngoato “so that he would agree on a compromised amount of money”. Asked whether the R250,000 compromise was for Gwabo, he said yes. “I am a mediator in this.”
The evidence leader tested that account against the messages in two ways. First, Mr Ngoato kept reporting to Mr Sindane on Morwa’s case — including a “proof of set down” for it — although Mr Sibanyoni said his interest lay only in Gwabo’s. Second, the timing: Gwabo had already been sentenced when Mr Ngoato wrote in May about work he could not do, which Advocate Chaskalson SC argued could only mean further work, such as an appeal. Mr Sibanyoni’s answer was that the payments concerned fees up to sentencing: “My instructions to Mr Ngoato, the matter is done. I will not do appeal.” A later message from Mr Ngoato said that, “due to your non-payment”, he was unable to proceed with the Gwabo appeal and that the family wanted answers.
Mr Sibanyoni’s account, then, is that a taxi association paid, at his request and in a dead man’s honour, and that he stepped in only to broker a discount. The attorney’s messages are the evidence against which that account was tested. The Commission has not made findings on it.