“Where is this rule written?” Local content, a 40% share and a Moloto Road quarry
Big public road contracts in South Africa often come with an expectation that some of the work, or some of the money, reaches businesses in the area the road runs through. On 29 September the Commission spent much of a day asking what that expectation actually requires — and where it stops.
The setting is the upgrade of the Moloto Road, which SANRAL is improving through Kwaggafontein. King Civil is the main contractor. Dr Ntuli, director of a company called Tengane Mining, has a quarry permit and supplied stone to the project. In a statement before the Commission he says that King Civil’s community liaison officer sent him to the chairperson of the local business forum, who in turn took him to Joe Sibanyoni.
Mr Sibanyoni’s account is that Dr Ntuli, who is from Middelburg, “did not have a local content to qualify for a certain percentage” on the Moloto Road work, and needed a local partner. “There is a certain percentage that you give to the locals, which is allocated as 30%,” he said. “It is a written rule.” Mr Sibanyoni, who says he has been “a Kwaggafontein person” since the age of five, was that partner. In return he was entitled to 40% of the profit on the arrangement.
“And where is this rule written?” the evidence leader asked. “I cannot take you to a specific rule,” Mr Sibanyoni replied; “the common understanding that is there, one needs to give 30% as a local content.” The chairperson offered the obvious place to look: such a requirement “may be specified in the tender document itself”.
The arithmetic then came apart under questioning. Mr Sibanyoni explained that the 30% is set aside and treated as “a full 100 on its own”, and that he and Dr Ntuli split that 60-40. The chairperson said this “no longer tallies” with the 30% rule as first described, and that it sounded as though the 40% was being fitted to the rule after the fact. Asked what entitled him to a share when he was never a shareholder in Tengane, Mr Sibanyoni answered: “It is a local content. There was no way Mr Ntuli could supply concrete or whatever supplying if I was not involved.”
Commissioner Baloyi then put the legal question directly. What did Mr Sibanyoni contribute? “Him partnering with me qualifies that as number one,” he said; the expertise lay with Dr Ntuli. “So it is really just having your name.” — “Yes.” “Which, on the face of it, seems like some kind of fronting, if that is what it was, that you bring nothing to the transaction.” — “You are correct, ja.” He added: “But do not run away from the local content, because, for me, that local content is the fundamental issue in this matter.”
The Commissioner’s reply sets out the distinction the whole exchange turned on: “local content means the locals must also provide a service. It is not simply giving the money.” A local share that pays for work done by local people is one thing. A share paid to someone for the use of his name and standing in the area is another — and the further question is what is behind the payment.
That further question is the one Dr Ntuli’s statement raises. It describes a first meeting in July 2021 at which, he says, he was told he had to pay “a protection fee” to operate in the area, and the Commission was shown a table of payments it put at over R2.29 million. Mr Sibanyoni first sought to claim privilege against self-incrimination on that allegation, then, pressed by the Commissioners, denied it: “No, not at all.” He also pointed out that a criminal case arising from the same events is pending in Delmas.
The Commission has made no finding on any of it. What it has put on the record is the test it applied: not whether a local partner was involved, but what that partner actually did.