When the courts themselves are the problem
A specialist from the World Bank spent a day at the Commission explaining what other countries did when they decided their own institutions could no longer clean themselves.
Laura Pop was careful about the word for it. These are “extraordinary mechanisms that are a little bit of a medicine of last resort” — not a first option, but something a country reaches for once the ordinary machinery of discipline and prosecution has stopped working.
The hardest version of the problem is the one she stated plainly: what happens when the capture has reached the top? If a country is “having capture in your Constitutional Court and the Supreme Court”, then the courts that would normally supervise a clean-up are themselves the thing that needs cleaning.
Kenya tried to answer that. A board was set up to vet sitting judges and magistrates. Everyone facing it was given notice of the concerns raised against them. The board spoke publicly about its mandate and invited complaints. At the start the whole board sat together on every case, so that it would build one consistent practice rather than several, and it began with the judges of the Court of Appeal — the most senior first.
One of the people doing that vetting was a retired South African Constitutional Court judge, Albie Sachs.
Moldova took a different route. Judges were moved temporarily to higher courts while the process ran, and those who passed received an immediate salary increase. Pop did not describe that as a reward. Salaries there had been held down for a specific reason: “the perception was we are giving higher salaries to corrupt people”. What passing the vetting changed was what the public was being asked to pay for — “we know that these are people with integrity, therefore we are comfortable with giving them higher salaries”.
For South Africa she described a “once-off deep cleansing exercise”: something done once, deliberately, and not turned into a permanent way of running a police service or a judiciary.
That framing matters for reading the rest of her evidence. Every example she gave came from a country that had already concluded the ordinary route had failed. The question left for the Commission is not whether the medicine works elsewhere. It is whether the diagnosis applies here.